Saturday, July 09, 2011

Praised and Criticised In Equal Measure

Zach Vaughan writes in Wandering Reveries somewhere in Texas (HERE):

A Libertarian in Leftywood writes in L.A.Liberrty:

‘The Invisible Hand: What Is it?’

‘It’s probably not what you think it is. The only mention of the invisible hand by Adam Smith in the Wealth of Nations occurs in Book IV, chp. 2, paragraph 9:

"By preferring the support of domestic to that of foreign industry, he intends only his own security; and by directing that industry in such a manner as its produce may be of the greatest value, he intends only his own gain, and he is in this, as in many other cases, led by an invisible hand to promote an end which was no part of his intention."

From this single mention, an entire mythology has arisen about the invisible hand and it’s role in the market. For quite some time, I’ve been reading Adam Smith’s Lost Legacy, which is a blog written by Gavin Kennedy, who spends much of his time countering the myth of the invisible hand. Today’s post addresses the invisible hand claims of the Rothbard/Mises school: Another False Attribution to Adam Smith. I recommend reading Mr Kennedy’s blog; it’s certainly given me a new, and more accurate, perspective of Adam Smith.’


Comment
An endorsement. At last!

Lost Legacy ploughs a lonely furrow and it is nice to receive evidence that somebody reads and finds in it something of value.

BUT, BUT!!

An angry Libertarian – is there any other type - (no name, that I could find) responds (HERE):

“That Cornuelle once studied under Mises does not make him part of the “Rothbard/Mises” school. To the contrary, one would describe him as primarily a neo-classical economist of a different sort entirely. One of the only Austrians who seems to ever use him with any regularity is Peter Boettke (whom that site quotes, and who tries to distance himself a bit from the Austrian mainstream).

Go ahead and perform a google search of the terms “cornuelle” and “austrian economics.” You will find that the vast majority of links are related to Boettke. If you try ”invisible hand” and “austrian economics,” it’s primarily Boettke and a couple by Peter Holcombe.

You will find no entry of Cornuelle in the Mises wiki; you will find no literature by Cornuelle available through Mises. In fact, the only mention of Cornuelle at mises.org is a letter to him by Murray Rothbard in the mid-50’s on an issue of disagreement. This is because Cornuelle was not an Austrian. Here is Rothbard himself explaining how Cornuelle very much lost his way from his more laissez-faire origins.

The fact of the matter is this: Mises, as far as I know, had never used the phrase “invisible hand.” The author’s closing paragraph attributing Cornuelle’s understanding of the invisible hand as having directly come while “[s]itting at the feet of Mises,” and taking “his teacher’s words as gospel” is at best speculative though likely a gross, irresponsible yet convenient fabrication.

I haven’t read everything Mises or all the great Austrians have ever written - this is true. But I’ve certainly read a far greater deal more than that author or you or most non-economists - and I’ve read enough to know that I’ve never come across the term “invisible hand” in any Austrian literature outside the two aforementioned economists and in historical context.
Which should be enough to laugh at the author’s opening statement of alleged discomfort. To jump from a small number of mentions to it being central to the school requires two assumptions: (1) no thinker may ever deviate from his primary philosophical course, and as such (2) any idea, no matter how little promoted by a small minority of adherents (even, with all due respect to Boettke and Holcombe, by minor players), must thus be attributed as part of the greater school of thought and even to a teacher who never said such a thing. This is, of course, preposterous.

Yes, a very small number (two, by my count - though perhaps there are other even lesser-known ones) of Austrians have sometimes used the invisible hand as a metaphor. And while Austrians may recognize Smith’s “invisible hand” as some catalyst of insight, Austrians in general simply do not subscribe to the “invisible hand” as an unseen, even magical force at work, just as they do not believe the market can ever reach equilibrium. As Mises and Rothbard and Kirzner all taught: the market is a process. It is the interactions of many using available, visible cues to make decisions. Each individual makes these decisions on his own behalf based on his own subjective criteria. Through this cooperative and competitive interplay - as results from the decentralization of an unfettered market - supply and scarcity is related, and demand and efficiency are discovered.

Perhaps this is mere nuance for those who believe an economy can be centrally planned, but the point is this: if you are to disparage the opinions and economists of the “Rothbard/Mises school” as it is so put, at least go after the opinions and economists who are actually best representative of it.
”

Comment
I re-posted the critical Comments in full. They contain some valid points in controversy with which I acknowledge.

I was making a wider point, not meaning to focus solely on Mises, et al, on the IH metaphor, but wider on the approach of Mises’ people with whom I have been acquainted over the years. I purchased and read Human Action in 2005 and was not impressed with its dependence on logicality, though its structure is an impressive argument. I discussed Rothbard’s take on Adam Smith on Lost Legacy some years back, and was totally unimpressed both by his assertions (he muddled Smith on the division of labour) and by his arrogant and abrupt manner. Several people who knew and met him confirmed my impressions from my reading of his personality, evident in his writing.

Despite what ‘Angry Libertarian’ (why are ‘Austrians’ so certain and so angry?) asserts, the IH metaphor is a regular source of my disputes with those of them I have met and read about.

However, I did not mean to imply anything about what Mises views were on Adam Smith’s use of the IH metaphor. I perhaps, wrongly, linked Cornuelle to Mises school, for which I apologise, and I hope in publishing “Angry Libertarian’s” in full the correction goes some way to making amends.

I accept "Angry Libertarian's" assurances that Mises did not make assertions about Adam Smith's use of the IH metaphor, and I shall bear that in mind in future and I shall distinguished between authoritative views on Austrian economics and less-informed persons who may wrongly assert t the contrary.

I do not deliberately ‘fabricate’ ideas or associations – Lost Legacy spends a great deal of time responding to such behaviours in others, especially on the myths of Adam Smith’s use of the IH metaphor, Smith’s beliefs in ‘laissez-faire’, the ‘night watchman state’ and even his alleged ‘labour theory of value’. Nor do I accept the notion of ‘equilibrium’ (general or partial), and much of the logico-centric use of mathematics to map human interactions.

Labels: , , ,

Thursday, August 14, 2008

Once More on Murray Rothbard and his Lack of Knowledge About Adam Smith

I have commented on Murray Rothbard’s writings on the division of labour in Wealth Of Nations before and return to it only because his introduction to "Freedom, Inequality, Primitivism, and the Division of Labor," which he wrote in 1970 and published in 1991, is republished by Lew Rockwell HERE:

Rothbard writes: “The Division of Labor”

“I have come to realize, since writing this essay, that I overweighted the contributions and importance of Adam Smith on the division of labor. And to my surprise, I did not sufficiently appreciate the contributions of Ludwig von Mises.
Despite the enormous emphasis on specialization and the division of labor in the Wealth of Nations, much of Smith's discussion was misplaced and misleading. In the first place, he placed undue importance on the division of labor within a factory (the famous pin-factory example), and scarcely considered the far more important division of labor among various industries and occupations.”


Comment

Smith didn’t place ‘undue importance on the division of labor within a factory (the famous pin-factory example), and scarcely considered the far more important division of labor among various industries and occupations’. Some readers of Wealth Of Nations placed that ‘undue importance’ on the pin factory themselves; then they ignored the rest of the chapter.

Smith gives a single paragraph to the pin factory (WN I.i.3: pp 14-15). If Murray Rothbard gave ‘undue importance’ to the pin factory that could only be because he didn’t read the rest of the 11 chapters that make up the chapter (I suspected this was the case when I wrote about Rothbard’s misunderstandings of the chapter a couple of years ago on Lost Legacy – I think we have proof of that suggestion now).

Look at the next paragraph in Wealth Of Nations:

‘The separation of different trades and employments from one another, seems to have taken place, in consequence of this advantage…” (WN I.i.4: p 16)
‘..How many different trades are employed in each branch of the linen and woollen manufactures, from the growers of the flax and the wool, to the bleachers and smoothers of the linen, or to the dyers and dressers of the cloth! (Ibid)

Then go to paragraph 11 (p 22) and read Smith's account of the multiple trades engaged in the manufacture of the ‘common artificer or day labourer’s woolen coat:

‘Observe the accommodation of the most common artificer or day-labourer in a civilized and thriving country, and you will perceive that the number of people of whose industry a part, though but a small part, has been employed in procuring him this accommodation, exceeds all computation. The woollen coat, for example, which covers the day-labourer, as coarse and rough as it may appear, is the produce of the joint labour of a great multitude of workmen. The shepherd, the sorter of the wool, the wool-comber or carder, the dyer, the scribbler, the spinner, the weaver, the fuller, the dresser, with many others, must all join their different arts in order to complete even this homely production. How many merchants and carriers, besides, must have been employed in transporting the materials from some of those workmen to others who often live in a very distant part of the country! how much commerce and navigation in particular, how many ship-builders, sailors, sail-makers, rope-makers, must have been employed in order to bring together the different drugs made use of by the dyer, which often come from the remotest corners of the world! What a variety of labour too is necessary in order to produce the tools of the meanest of those workmen! To say nothing of such complicated machines as the ship of the sailor, the mill of the fuller, or even the loom of the weaver, let us consider only what a variety of labour is requisite in order to form that very simple machine, the shears with which the shepherd clips the wool. The miner, the builder of the furnace for smelting the ore, the feller of the timber, the burner of the charcoal to be made use of in the smelting-house, the brick-maker, the brick-layer, the workmen who attend the furnace, the mill-wright, the forger, the smith, must all of them join their different arts in order to produce them. Were we to examine, in the same manner, all the different parts of his dress and household furniture, the coarse linen shirt which he wears next his skin, the shoes which cover his feet, the bed which he lies on, and all the different parts which compose it, the kitchen-grate at which he prepares his victuals, the coals which he makes use of for that purpose, dug from the bowels of the earth, and brought to him perhaps by a long sea and a long land carriage, all the other utensils of his kitchen, all the furniture of his table, the knives and forks, the earthen or pewter plates upon which he serves up and divides his victuals, the different hands employed in preparing his bread and his beer, the glass window which lets in the heat and the light, and keeps out the wind and the rain, with all the knowledge and art requisite for preparing that beautiful and happy invention, without which these northern parts of the world could scarce have afforded a very comfortable habitation, together with the tools of all the different workmen employed in producing those different conveniencies; if we examine, I say, all these things, and consider what a variety of labour is employed about each of them, we shall be sensible that without the assistance and co-operation of many thousands, the very meanest person in a civilized country could not be provided, even according to what we very falsely imagine, the easy and simple manner in which he is commonly accommodated.’

Comment
Could it be expressed any clearer? The fact that Rothbard missed this example of the interconnection of numerous supply chains to produce so simple a product as a woolen coat, located in places miles away, even overseas, with the heavy implication that if you take more complex products, the inter-connectedness would be even greater, says much about Rothbard’s lack of thoroughness about Adam Smith, perhaps from distant loss of memory, or from an original ignorance of the contents of Wealth Of Nations.

‘Secondly, there is the mischievous contradiction between the discussions in Book I and Book V in the Wealth of Nations. In Book I, the division of labor is hailed as responsible for civilization as well as economic growth, and is also praised as expanding the alertness and intelligence of the population. But in Book V the division of labor is condemned as leading to the intellectual and moral degeneration of the same population, and to the loss of their "intellectual, social, and martial virtues." These complaints about the division of labor as well as similar themes in Smith's close friend Adam Ferguson, strongly influenced the griping about "alienation" in Marx and later socialist writers.

Comment
Again it is evidence of Rothbard’s lack of knowledge about Wealth Of Nations.

The first chapter in Book I is about the prodigious productive powers of the division labour from ‘increased dexterity’, the ‘saving of time’ and ‘the great number of machines which facilitate and abridge labour’ (other people made the ‘machines’ in other trades!). (WN I.i.5: p 17)

The increase in the output of the ‘necessaries, conveniences, and amusements of life’ constitutes economic growth and the spread of opulence, especially to the labouring poor.

The paragraph in Book V (WN V.i.f.50: pp 781-2) is in the midst of Smith’s argument in favour of education for all through ‘little schools’ in each village, paid for local public funds (on the Scottish model). His book seeks to influence the literate readers from the income groups who would have to pay for universal education if it was legislated for in Parliament, which meant he had to persuade legislators and those who influence them to pass the necessary laws. This can be seen by reading the paragraphs:

‘Of the Expence of the Institutions for the Education of Youth’

'In the progress of the division of labour, the employment of the far greater part of those who live by labour, that is, of the great body of the people, comes to be confined to a few very simple operations, frequently to one or two. But the understandings of the greater part of men are necessarily formed by their ordinary employments. The man whose whole life is spent in performing a few simple operations, of which the effects are perhaps always the same, or very nearly the same, has no occasion to exert his understanding or to exercise his invention in finding out expedients for removing difficulties which never occur. He naturally loses, therefore, the habit of such exertion, and generally becomes as stupid and ignorant as it is possible for a human creature to become. The torpor of his mind renders him not only incapable of relishing or bearing a part in any rational conversation, but of conceiving any generous, noble, or tender sentiment, and consequently of forming any just judgment concerning many even of the ordinary duties of private life. Of the great and extensive interests of his country he is altogether incapable of judging, and unless very particular pains have been taken to render him otherwise, he is equally incapable of defending his country in war. The uniformity of his stationary life naturally corrupts the courage of his mind, and makes him regard with abhorrence the irregular, uncertain, and adventurous life of a soldier. It corrupts even the activity of his body, and renders him incapable of exerting his strength with vigour and perseverance in any other employment than that to which he has been bred. His dexterity at his own particular trade seems, in this manner, to be acquired at the expence of his intellectual, social, and martial virtues. But in every improved and civilized society this is the state into which the labouring poor, that is, the great body of the people, must necessarily fall, unless government takes some pains to prevent it.’ (WN V.i.f: 50: pp 781-2)

‘The education of the common people requires, perhaps, in a civilized and commercial society the attention of the public more than that of people of some rank and fortune.'
(52)

‘It is otherwise with the common people. They have little time to spare for education. Their parents can scarce afford to maintain them even in infancy. As soon as they are able to work they must apply to some trade by which they can earn their subsistence. That trade, too, is generally so simple and uniform as to give little exercise to the understanding, while, at the same time, their labour is both so constant and so severe, that it leaves them little leisure and less inclination to apply to, or even to think of, anything else.’(53)

‘For a very small expence the public can facilitate, can encourage, and can even impose upon almost the whole body of the people the necessity of acquiring those most essential parts of education.’ (54)

‘The public can facilitate this acquisition by establishing in every parish or district a little school, where children may be taught for a reward so moderate that even a common labourer may afford it; the master being partly, but not wholly, paid by the public, because, if he was wholly, or even principally, paid by it, he would soon learn to neglect his business. In Scotland the establishment of such parish schools has taught almost the whole common people to read, and a very great proportion of them to write and account. In England the establishment of charity schools has had an effect of the same kind, though not so universally, because the establishment is not so universal. If in those little schools the books, by which the children are taught to read, were a little more instructive than they commonly are, and if, instead of a little smattering of Latin, which the children of the common people are sometimes taught there, and which can scarce ever be of any use to them, they were instructed in the elementary parts of geometry and mechanics, the literary education of this rank of people would perhaps be as complete as it can be. There is scarce a common trade which does not afford some opportunities of applying to it the principles of geometry and mechanics, and which would not therefore gradually exercise and improve the common people in those principles, the necessary introduction to the most sublime as well as to the most useful sciences.’
And then the clincher: if his readers were not convinced yet by the education argument alone, Smith appeals to their fear of the consequences of leaving the common people ignorant for want of a small expense to educate the children:

‘A man without the proper use of the intellectual faculties of a man, is, if possible, more contemptible than even a coward, and seems to be mutilated and deformed in a still more essential part of the character of human nature. Though the state was to derive no advantage from the instruction of the inferior ranks of people, it would still deserve its attention that they should not be altogether uninstructed. The state, however, derives no inconsiderable advantage from their instruction. The more they are instructed the less liable they are to the delusions of enthusiasm and superstition, which, among ignorant nations, frequently occasion the most dreadful disorders. An instructed and intelligent people, besides, are always more decent and orderly than an ignorant and stupid one. They feel themselves, each individually, more respectable and more likely to obtain the respect of their lawful superiors, and they are therefore more disposed to respect those superiors. They are more disposed to examine, and more capable of seeing through, the interested complaints of faction and sedition, and they are, upon that account, less apt to be misled into any wanton or unnecessary opposition to the measures of government. In free countries, where the safety of government depends very much upon the favourable judgment which the people may form of its conduct, it must surely be of the highest importance that they should not be disposed to judge rashly or capriciously concerning it
.’

Comment
Rothbard never got the point. He was a selective quotation searcher and not a reader.

To paraphrase from Rothbard: I have come to realize, since writing these comments, that I overweighted the contributions and importance of Murray Rothbard on economics. And to my surprise, I did not sufficiently realize how weak he was on his knowledge of Adam Smith.

Labels: