Wednesday, October 12, 2011

Pause for a Reflection

Hywell Williams, an historian, author, and columnist, writes in his Daily Mail Blog:

“Economics: the futile predictions of a pointless 'science'”

HERE:

“Looking at how trade and business patterns of manufacturing, investment and productivity have operated in the past is well worth doing. And the people who pioneered that investigation in the 18th- century - such as the famous Adam Smith - called their subject 'political economy'. They were under no illusions that they were pursuing a science which might yield laws in the way that physics often does. Smith and co. understood that economic behaviour and phenomena are always variable. They are part of the life of human beings in society, and since men and women are not machines their behaviour in matters of consumption, production and investment simply can't be predicted.

We can have trends and probabilities of course. At some point demand for some goods - let's take oil as an example - having been elastic, will stop being so. But nobody can ever predict at what point people will decide they're not prepared to pay a high price for oil any more.

'Political economy' was a good phrase since it showed how politics and social life generally give a context and a meaning to economic behaviour. But that wasn't good enough for all those economists who laboured over their quasi-mathematical models in the late 20th century. Career building was all important here. All those grants from supposedly respectable research councils - all the subsidies and the 'funding' - were only available if economics could be made to appear to be a subject that could actually give you mastery of the world here and now, and in the future as well. It was meant to be the key to a predicted prosperity. 'Approve my funding mechanism for a macro-economic study and you - secretary of state - will learn how to produce economic prosperity and thereby ensure your party's re-election'.

But there's a very simple reason why all the economic charts in the world will never really demonstrate what might, or might not, work as a policy. At any one time, and especially during a major crisis as at the moment, there are in fact all sorts of economic policies that are in place. A bit of quantitative easing here - a spot of inflation toleration there, supplemented by a tightening of the money supply if that seems necessary or some restructuring of the tax regime. A time lag then occurs. Its length can never be predicted. Some people take a long time to respond to economic prompting. Others may be quicker off the mark, while yet others carry on being indifferent
.”

Comment
I make no claims that Hywell Williams is particularly perceptive, nor that his ideas about economics are necessarily suspect for his not being recognised as a main-line orthodox economist. I was drawn to his article for its theme that struck a chord about Adam Smith and the current fashion for economics as being a predictive science – though, of course, there is much controversy about the reliability of competing predictions by economists, including among economists.

Adam Smith did not make predictions about what might, let alone what would, happen in the circumstances in which he lived. He always looked backwards historically, trying to explain what had happened. He made specific recommendations about how certain economic affairs ought to be managed to deal with specific problems that he regarded were unsatisfactory and could be improved upon and tried to identify why specific outcomes were less than beneficial compared to what they could be if they were arranged differently.

Thus, Smith’s critique of mercantile political economy – his ‘very violent attack on the whole commercial system of Great Britain’ – had much to say critically about recent 18th-century events in intervention policy by sovereigns and legislators, by ‘merchants and manufacturers’, and assorted interest groups who had influenced the kings since medieval times. These criticisms of the interventions of kings through their governments and laws were not an absolute hostility to state interventions, as is often presented by modern economists and political activists. They were measured and specific observations on the, often deleterious, consequences, of political – and theological – policies by people who didn’t (and often still do not) know
what they were doing.

In spreading his criticisms of economics to modern economists, Hywell Williams makes some telling points about the root causes of the hubris of much of modern economics. Our science is not physics, despite the pretensions of the priesthood, lightly clothed in a mathematics resting on a fatal fault-line that Smith (an accomplished mathematician by 18th-century standards) called ‘men of system’, who are ‘apt to be very wise’ in their ‘conceit’, who ‘seems to imagine’ that they ‘can arrange the different pieces upon a chess-board’, where ‘the pieces have no other principle of motion besides that which the hand impresses upon them’, when in fact ‘in the great chess-board of human society, every single piece has a principle of motion of its own, altogether different from that which the legislature might chuse to impress on them’ (TMS VI.ii.2.17:233-34).

Carbon atoms, like all others, respond to forces in exactly the same way in the solar system, and probably throughout the universe, according to their common nature. People, however, are different because they are different. They are not infinitely predictable. Some choose a life of crime, others are saintly, and all stations in-between and beyond are observably different. Nor is tomorrow’s economy predictable; bets can be taken, and some will win, others lose. These suggest a degree of humility is required among economists. An imaginary world endorsed with its terms by mathematics and computing power does not the real world replicate. Smith understood that barrier to predictability; ‘tis a pity that Samuelson’s generation did not.

So, instead of taking cheap shots at Hywell Williams, and his ilk, we should pause and reflect on our limitations and try to understand more about how we got to where we are in our understanding, and rely less of what our equations tell us. Perhaps we would have less cause provoke the Hywell Williamson’s contributing to the current discourses about the current recession, what caused it, and what might be done about it, given our limited knowledge of how the real world works, or rather doesn’t.

Labels: ,

Thursday, November 26, 2009

An Excellent Review of The Failings of Neo-classical Economics

In Reality Base Blog (HERE)a book review by John Gray in the London Review of Books, is reported (25 November):

“Animal spirits and what else is wrong with neoclassical economics”

“A much discussed book this year has been Animal Spirits: How Human Psychology Drives the Economy, and Why It Matters for Global Capitalism by George Akerlof and Robert Shiller.

He credits Akerlof and Shiller for their evisceration of neoclassical economics for assuming at its core rational behavior of human beings—conceiving them to be a species, homo economicus, that is not us. Gray goes beyond this and points out that even if we all were homo economicus, important parts of the future are always unknowable and cannot be quantified and factored into market decisions as probabilities. A third theme of the review is the hubris of the neoclassical school in assuming that the magic beans they had discovered would work in any environment and that, indeed, no other doctrine would lead to economic abundance. Unaccountably and regrettably, these ideologues appear not to have noticed in the real world the massive contradictions to that view. A few excerpts:

. . . . The trouble with prevailing theories, in Akerlof and Shiller's view, is that they assume human beings are more rational than they actually are. 'This book, which draws on an emerging field called behavioural economics, describes how the economy really works,' they claim. 'It accounts for how it works when people really are human, that is, possessed of all-too-human animal spirits.' . . . .

. . . . If economists have failed to explain repeated crises, it is because they have interpreted economic activity through an unreal model of rational decision-making. Thinking of human behaviour in this way allows them to claim a high degree of precision for their discipline, which is presented as a kind of applied mathematics. But they have left psychology out of their equations.

. . . . The fact that markets are flawed seems novel only in the context of the economic orthodoxy that prevailed between the wars, and in the run-up to the recent crisis. It is wrong to imply, as Akerlof and Shiller do, that the classical economists believed otherwise. 'Just as Adam Smith's invisible hand is the keynote of classical economics,' they write, 'Keynes's animal spirits are the keynote to a different view of the economy – a view that explains the underlying instabilities of capitalism.' Here they are endorsing the caricature of Smith propagated by neoliberal ideologues anxious to confer a distinguished patrimony on an illegitimate intellectual offspring. . . .

If Akerlof and Shiller's grip on the history of economic thought is shaky, they also fail to grasp why Keynes rejected the idea that markets are self-stabilising. . . .

[I]n his canonical General Theory of Employment, Interest and Money (1936) he concluded that there was no way anyone could make forecasts. Future interest rates and prices, new inventions and the likelihood of a European war cannot be predicted: there is no 'basis on which to form any calculable probability whatever. We simply do not know!' For Keynes, markets are unstable less because they are driven by emotion than because the future is unknowable. To suggest that the source of market volatility is unreason is to imply that if people were fully rational markets could be stable. But even if people were affectless calculating machines they would still be ignorant of the future, and markets would still be volatile. The root cause of market instability is the insuperable limitation of human knowledge. . . . .

The central flaw of the economic orthodoxy against which Keynes fought in the 1930s was to imagine that an insoluble problem – human ignorance of the future – had been solved. The error was repeated in the 1990s, when economists came to believe that complex mathematical formulae could tame uncertainty in the murky world of derivatives. . . .

. . . . Hayek said that governments could never know enough to plan the economy successfully – a claim vindicated by the miserable record of central planning in Communist countries. At the same time, he attributed near omniscience to markets, and never doubted that if left to its own devices the economy would liquidate mistaken investments and return to equilibrium. Against this, Keynes had shown that there is no market mechanism that ensures revival; economic contraction can be self-reinforcing, and only government action can then create a way out
."

Comment
This is more like it. Not having read Akerlof and Shiller’s book, I cannot blindly endorse everything they may have said, but their charge against “Homo economicus”, also made regularly on Lost Legacy, and their objections to mathematical modeling of economics, which precludes humans behaving as they really are, is very welcome.

Nobody actually reading Adam Smith would conclude that humans are, or will become, rational calculating machines, or that economies are closed systems in general equilibrium, and thus predictable, let alone always prone to the working for the public good in a Dr Panglossian “best of all possible worlds”.

That markets are better, in an acceptable sense, than their alternatives is a modest requirement, as the experience of Soviet central planning and the accompanying tyranny, is adequate testimony. But that is where we start from, not where we end.

The hubris of a belief in a predictable world, and events in it, is a serious flaw in the modern “science” of economics. Smith, like the later Keynes, did not endorse the myths of predictability – hence there are few, perhaps only one or two, specific predictions in Wealth Of Nations - one being that the former British colonies in North America would be wealthier (measured by the “annual output of the necessaries, conveniences, and amusements of life” within a century of 1776).

Nor was the 20th-century re-invention of the metaphor of "an invisible hand" as a comforting assurance that whatever the moral failings, or externality-induced misery, that was inflicted by individual "merchants and manufacturers" (to which we can add some governments some of the time, and a few governments all of the time), on the rest of society, was somehow a social benefit.

It wasn't, and economics as a "science" can only delude its practitioners into believing such nonsense by denuding its "models" of human beings. This charge cannot be made against Adam Smith.

Labels: , ,

Wednesday, December 03, 2008

Give me Two-Handed Economists Any Day

Dragos Cabat writes in 1asigro.com (‘all about insurance’), Roumania, HERE:

“Corporate Capitalism on the edge”

“The aim is that, through the state's intervention into these companies' operations and ownership, the corporations situation to recover and investors to calm down (the depositors too, in the banks' case), but there are no guarantees for the management process improvement. That is why the market has no positive reactions towards the government's interference into the economy, accepting them only for a short period of time. For the economic climate betterment it is necessary to reform the corporative capitalist system through "breaking" the big companies and giving the owners the real control over their activities (a trend started in the '80's, but abandoned because of the globalization). A fact is for certain: we are living through interesting changes and the future capitalism will probably look more as the one that was theoretically described by Adam SMITH over 200 years ago
.”

Comment
This makes a change. Almost everything I read about the current financial turmoil (or is more like treacle?) suggests that corporate capitalism is over, but few regard it as going back to the small corporate entities of Adam Smith’s day.

Most seem to predict (few with regrets) that Adam Smith is to be rejected too, especially with the myths that have adorned mentions of him, laissez-faire, invisible hands, and all such guff (of which, for the record, he was wholly innocent).

Dragos Cabat does not say much about how this ‘new’ world is about to be drawn up, agreed and created. Probably just as well. Predictions about the future, especially those radically different to an existing present, usually prove embarrassing to those who make them.

Like Adam Smith, I think it best not to make predictions. It’s always a trade off and in this sense the ‘two-handed economist’ is positively saintly compared to the kind who gives definite answers to complex problems, especially those involving human beings.

Labels: