Wednesday, March 21, 2012

On the Road to Redemption?

Scott Galupo writes in USNEWS.com HERE

He quotes August Heckscher essay, "Where Are the American Conservatives?" in which he declared “it to be as relevant today as when it was published in 1953”:

“The concept of a pure conservatism, its pattern ‘laid up in heaven’, was an illusion; it was in fact the same illusion that had possessed the Liberals and the Utopian democrats through the nineteenth century. That the conservatives should have fallen under its spell was particularly strange, for traditionally the conservatives mistrust an excessive rationalism—they know that the world moves by habit, by values, by inherited faith, quite as much as it moves by getting new ideas. The conservatives, when they are in their right mind, avoid tearing up the roots of something they do not like almost as instinctively as they avoid tearing up the roots of institutions and procedures of which they approve. The fact that American conservatives to so large a measure forgot, or never learned, this healthy prudence and this basic tolerance, I can only attribute to the fact that they had grown so uncontrollably angry. In attacking the New Deal they became inflexible in their thinking, unresponsive to the settled expectations and tacit consents of the great public; and they wanted instead to impose a doctrinaire program of their own.”

Scott Galupo adds:

“Replacing one's notion of Nanny with a sterner Daddy will not restore the prelapsarian paradise of Adam Smith's Invisible Hand and Friedrich von Hayek's Spontaneous Order—because those paradises never existed to begin with.”

Comment
This may be an example of someone waking up and realising that he cannot smell the coffee because there is none to smell.

Samuelson’s authoritative myth (and getting more authoritative through the following decades) of Adam Smith’s ‘selfish’ invisible hand that nevertheless miraculously benefitted society had hardly got the traction by 1953 that it was to acquire a few years from his highly successful textbook: Economics: an introductory analysis McGraw-Hill (1948) – achieving 5 million sales by 2010.

It took a little time for Samuelson’s, or his teachers’, oral invention to spread into western consciousness, as graduates across the world went out to teach on other campuses, or claim through the media and democratic politics that there was salvation in the optimism in markets, nowhere free, but freer in the ‘land of the free’ than in war-shattered Europe, and incomparably freer than the drab communist central-planning regimes of Soviet occupied states, and to a much lesser extent, in Western European social-democratic states and in their newly independent former colonial states of the British Empire.

The Soviets grabbed East European territory after World War 2, and their communist allies grabbed China, but all was not lost because the West had the “miraculous magic”, wrongly attributed to Adam Smith, of the “invisible hand” that worked its wonders in markets irrespective of the selfish motives of those who were “led” by it.

Those who wanted a “doctrinaire program of their own” found it in “Adam Smith’s invisible hand”, which the Soviets could not match, despite Oscar Lange’s attempt to portray central planners as doing the work of an invisible hand, but only ‘better’. Such unconvincing fantasies were of no avail compared to the success of post-war capitalism, supposedly with its genuine invisible hand in its markets.

Events showed the superiority of the democratic capitalist economies, particularly in the collapse of Soviet communism and the opening by communist China by aligning its imitative state producing for capitalist world markets. With the economic crisis in Western capitalist economies from reckless over spending and borrowing, their over confidence was challenged globally.

Scott Galupo reacts with his conclusion that “the prelapsarian paradise of Adam Smith's Invisible Hand” never existed. He’s right, but that truth was available to anybody who consulted Adam Smith’s Works and read the very limited contexts in which he used the metaphor (only twice in fact), and certainly he never associated it with the blank cheque of “selfishness” and the assertion that society automatically would be better off.

This last assertion, shouted everywhere in the US on every media, is contradicted in Adam Smith’s “Wealth Of Nations” , much as the “selfish” libel is contradicted in his “Moral Sentiments”. Smith laid into the selfish behaviours of “merchants and manufacturers”, many of whom acted directly contrary to the interests of consumers (tariffs, prohibitions, the anti-labour combination acts, settlement acts, the town guilds, apprentices acts, and all attempts at narrowing competition to raise prices).

It is a mystery beyond explanation why so many voices, even among academics, simultaneously believed in the myth of the selfish invisible hand and were unaware of the content (not just quotes from) Adam Smith’s two works.

I put it down to a form of collective amnesia much closer to a theology than to social science.

Labels: ,

Tuesday, March 06, 2012

How Modern Economists and Journalists Fail

Christine Shearer, a postdoctoral fellow in Sociology at the University of California, Santa Barbara, reviews John Cassidy: “How Markets Fail: The Logic of Economic Calamities”, (Farrar, Straus and Giroux, 2010). She is a journalist at “The New Yorker” and posts on Left Eye On Books HERE

“Is faulty economics at the root of t he global financial crisis?”

“Cassidy begins with Adam Smith’s “The Wealth of Nations,” widely regarded as the precursor to the modern discipline of economics. Smith laid out a vision in which rational self-interest and competition can paradoxically lead to the greater good for everyone and national economic prosperity. As Smith put it, each individual “intends only his own gain, and he is in this [is] led by an invisible hand to promote an end which was no part of his intention.” In making this argument, Smith’s vision of how societies and economies operate was highly utopian, as Robert Heilbroner’s “The Worldly Philosophers” explores
.”

Comment
Christine Shearer (a postdoctoral fellow), does not say where in his texts Adam Smith claimed that “rational self-interest and competition can paradoxically lead to the greater good for everyone and national economic prosperity”, nor what is meant by “rational” self-interest (a similar popular assertion often presented as “enlightened” self interest”). It is too easy to slip from modern language to read into Adam Smith what is not there, as it is to find in his Works a “leftwing” Adam Smith.

She also allows Cassidy to get away with doctoring a quotation from Adam Smith to give an entirely different slant on it compared to Adam Smith’s clear language:

“Here is the full quotation from Adam Smith (with Cassidy’s rather reduced and brutal version emphasised):

“But the annual revenue of every society is always precisely equal to the exchangeable value of the whole annual produce of its industry, or rather is precisely the same thing with that exchangeable value. As every individual, therefore, endeavours as much as he can both to employ his capital in the support of domestick industry, and so to direct that industry that its produce may be of the greatest value; every individual necessarily labours to render the annual revenue of the society as great as he can. He generally, indeed, neither intends to promote the publick interest, nor knows how much he is promoting it. By preferring the support of domestick to that of foreign industry, he intends only his own security; and by directing that industry in such a manner as its produce may be of the greatest value, he intends only his own gain, and he is in this, as in many other cases, led by an invisible hand to promote an end which was no part of his intention” (WN IV.ii.9: 456 – also read paragraphs 1 – 8 to confirm the Smith’s restricted context).

Smith’s was not a general statement of what every individual merchant in a society did, but what some specific merchants did, who “intend their own security” and who were averse to sending their capital out of their direct sight and control, into the “foreign trade of consumption” - see the previous 8 paragraphs of Book IV, chapter 2, Wealth Of Nations.

Cassidy (like many others who quote but do not report Smith’s entire argument) misses out Smith’s clear statement of the specific case he identified of some, but not all merchants, preferred to invest in “domestick to that of foreign industry”. This group “intend only [their] own security”, and, in consequence, they “direct that [domestick] industry [so] that its produce may be of the greatest value”. This means that “every individual” in the specific group he identified (not necessarily every individual merchant in a commercial society), so motivated, “necessarily labours to render the annual revenue of the society as great as he can.”

This is not a general statement of what happens universally across an economy in every individual merchant. Adam Smith states the simple consequence of the actions of those specific merchants who invest only at home: they necessarily add to annual domestic revenue (GDP) by exactly the arithmetical amount of their domestic capital investment – the whole is the sum of its parts! It is not a “vision” or anything like one. It was a limited quantitative consequence of the risk aversion of some, but not all “individual” merchants.

Clearly, foreign trade was an important element of British GNP, but a sizeable number of other merchants did send their capital abroad in the quite extensive British merchant marine (thanks to the Navigation Acts from Cromwell’s time), thereby denuding “domestick industry” of that quantity represented by their capital, which necessarily reduced UK “annual revenue and employment”, though for other reasons not gone into here, annual GDP would be smaller if nobody invested abroad. Smith, remember, favoured overseas trade. Exports to buy imports added to the range of domestic consumption in the form of imports, assuming domestic “merchants and manufacturers”, and other self-interested parties did not prevent imports by agitating to impose mercantile tariffs and prohibitions, the main target of Smith’s “violent attack” in his critique in Wealth Of Nations.

That modern economists continue to misread Adam Smith – or more correctly, simply quote blindly the assertions of others without reading Wealth Of Nations – is itself a comment on modern ‘scholarship’, and perhaps on modern journalism too that repeats these myths – what happened to news journalism’s fabled “fact checkers”?

Christine Shearer takes from Cassidy that Adam Smith held the view “that individual self-interest operating in a competitive marketplace produces the conditions under which a society thrives paved the way for utility maximization theories [from the late 19th-century] and general equilibrium theories, [from post-1940s] leading to models of self-equilibrating, rational markets balanced out by the forces of supply and demand. Cassidy notes [she tells us] that many of these same modern theorists are aware of the shortcomings of their ideas: that “they often only held up under certain conditions (and often very restrictive ones), or could not be demonstrated empirically, making them grounded more in abstract equations and theory than observable reality. He argues that, in fact, it is well-established in mathematical economics that there are several problems with the theories, particularly that there is no guarantee that an economy will settle on an “efficient” rest point. These theorists, Cassidy argues, therefore rarely posed their studies as prescriptions for government policy.”

This type of thinking gave “credibility to the ideology of the ‘Efficient Markets Hypothesis’ as the best approximation for how financial markets operate”, with results that are evident today. True, some financial firms made profits on such theories, but as many others made losses. None of this had anything to do with Adam Smith. He was dragged into supporting these theories, and especially those associating him with the “invisible hand”, when, in fact, he was innocent of any connection with them. The views that he was complicit are inventions and distortions (of the kind that originated in misquotations of the famous “invisible-hand” paragraph, like those of Christine’s above), from the 1940s, which had more to do with the Cold War decades, than they had in historical fact. For which, Paul Samuelson was a major instigator of the claim from 1948 that Adam Smith supposedly set the “invisible hand” myth running, so that today that belief is rampant.

I note (not as criticism – people have a right to believe what they like) that Christine Shearer is of a “leftish’ disposition. It is somewhat ironic that she criticises “rightish” theories but, apparently, she too has bought into the same myths about Adam Smith, which myths achieved traction during the Cold War in the Western effort to counter Soviet central planning as an alternative to commercial markets, with the planners taking over the invented role of the “invisible hand” (see Oscar Lange’s books from 1938-47). Such myths impugn Adam Smith’s legacy. He died over 150 years before the Cold War came to be part of modern intellectual discourse and lasted until around the 1990s.

Labels: , ,

Friday, January 13, 2012

More Good Sense From Western Washington University

Brandon Dupont, associate professor of economics at Western Washington University writes (12 January) for his Economic Incubator Blog HERE

“On the Fallacies of Free Markets”

“Misconceptions about “free markets” are not unusual but here’s the latest from Justin Semion, with some of my comments below:
According to Semion:

‘The concept of the “invisible hand of the market” underlies classical and neoclassical economic theories advocating for a free market economy, one with no government regulation. In summary, free market theory proposes that supply and demand in the unregulated marketplace naturally reach a state of equilibrium where the maximum possible social good is achieved.’


[To which Brandon replies:]

“First, the “invisible hand of the market” is widely attributed to Adam Smith, yet Smith did not intend it as a theory of markets and only mentioned it once in the Wealth of Nations. Paul Samuelson used the phrase to provide some color to his efficiency theorem of competitive markets, but it is not due to Adam Smith. More importantly, no free market economy (especially the version proposed by Smith) is one in which there is “no government regulation.” Smith himself proposed a variety of government regulations as do nearly all modern economists.”

Comment
Follow the link and read the rest of Brandon’s excellent critique of Justin Semion’s (of Presidio Graduate School) piece. Brandon writes a correct representation of Adam Smith’s views on markets, government, and the invisible hand.

Justin’s piece is typical of modern economics as taught on most campuses and is published in Triple Pundit HERE

The more professors who critique the views of economists like Justin Semion, the better.

Labels: ,

Saturday, December 03, 2011

Oh, What a Web of Fantasy Modern Economists Weave

I was sent this clip by a reader of Lost Legacy a few days ago.** It speaks for itself, but follow the link for the full story. HERE

"...GlaxoSmithKline and other pharma giants to produce enough expensive vaccines for children who need them most but can afford them least? The answer, Gates increasingly believed, lay in making Adam Smith’s invisible hand more visible, giving the newly formed market a benevolent shove in the direction of free enterprise."

Comment
What exactly is meant by “making Adam Smith’s invisible hand more visible” is not stated. Forbes assumes readers know what it means. If someone can make ‘more visible’ which, by repetition is ‘invisible’. Readers of Adam Smith and Lost Legacy will - or should - know it is a simple metaphor, much used in the 17th and 18th centuries before Adam Smith used it.

Smith used it to represent metaphorically something else, which he identified in the first case (Moral Sentments) as the unintentional behaviour of ‘rich and unfeeling landlords’, who, in feeding their dependent slaves, servants, and serfs, unintentionally assured the procreation (a public good) and the continuation of the species, and crucially their own continuation (no food for serfs; no labour from serfs), and in the second case (Wealth Of Nations), the IH metaphorically represented the behaviour of some, but not all merchants, who, concerned for the security of their capital if they sent it abroad, preferred to invest in “domestick industry” instead, thus unintentionally adding to “domestic investment and employment”, which benefitted the public, especially the poor.

Only modern economists converted this well known and clear metaphor into a general and actual noun for something believed to be ‘real’ and applied it to markets, supply and demand, prices, and almost everything else in economics (and well beyond into fantasy land – see the Looney Tunes series on Lost Legacy).

So what Forbes meant – and allegedly Gates too – is that this shared fantasy, attributed crassly to Adam Smith since the 1940s, following Paul Samuelson, exists almost with religious devotion (the ‘hand of God’, etc.,) and even turns selfish actions into public benefits. Though as the broader implications for such non-Smithian notions began to strike home, even Samuelson, responsible single-handedly almost, for the spread of the nonsense, began to backtrack slightly and imperceptibly in later editions of his phenomenally successful 1948-2010 textbook, Economics: an introductory analysis, by declaring that an invisible hand could only work in perfectly competitive conditions, and not in the mixed economy of modern capitalism.

Unfortunately, Forbes and Bill Gates, and most modern economists haven’t yet realized this truth, which Samuelson belatedly realized, and which Adam Smith, bless him, had never said anything at all to lead anyone to think that he had, 335 years earlier.

[** Lost Legacy welcomes readers' clips and leads and always tries to use them - anonymously, should you require; with acknowledgments by name as requested.]

Labels: ,

Saturday, November 19, 2011

Socialism and Capitalism Are Quite Different

Andy Logar posts (19 November) in American Thinker HERE

“Socialism's Fundamental Flaws”

“In the Soviet model the state owned the means of production thus all workers were employed by the state -- essentially each working for everyone else, the collective, but not directly for themselves. This was effectively a compulsory altruism which, because not being a primary human drive, introduced a fatal systemic flaw to an economy so bereft of incentives as to engender the famous Russian quip: ‘We pretend to work and they pretend to pay us.’

“As if one were not enough, the second fatal flaw was the elimination of the free market and its replacement by the planned economy -- where supply and demand were in the hands of technocrats and not the invisible hand of free-market capitalism
.”

Comment
Be clear, I have no sympathy for the ‘socialism’ practiced in the Soviet Union or elsewhere, of which criticism by Andy Logar I broadly agree, but I have no confidence in his characterization of the pre-Soviet economy as ‘the free market”, nor as replacing “free market capitalism”. It was largely a pre-capitalist continent, dominated by a repressive oligarchy and a semi-feudal countryside.

Stark contrasts between two extreme poles of description, as is usual in such ideological posts, do not help clarity in the argument that Logar’s post purports to make. He even makes an unfortunate and questionable statement in describing the Soviet model of state ownership as: “essentially each working for everyone else, the collective, but not directly for themselves”. It was the French, 18th-century Physiocrat, Mirabeau, who correctly commented that in markets, each individual thinks they work for themselves, but in actuality they ‘work for others’. How true!

In seeking to realise our self-interests we unintentionally serve the self-interests of others in the mediation that necessarily is the voluntary exchange process. No market would function if people tried to work only ‘for themselves’; their voluntary exchange behaviours must necessarily take account of the self-interest of others (see Adam Smith in Book 1, chapter 2, Wealth of Nations: ‘address the self-love of others, not your own’). That is what free markets bring about. In contrast, in Soviet Socialist Systems everybody in fact worked, under direct compulsion, for the State that decides what they and everybody else gets in return. This is the essential difference between markets and socialism.

Turning to Andy Logar’s sentence: “the planned economy -- where supply and demand were in the hands of technocrats and not the invisible hand of free-market capitalism”, we confront another source of Logar’s error.

It was Oscar Lange, the Marxist, pro-Soviet economist-cum-technocrat, who taught at Michigan and Chicago in the 1930s and 1940s, and who penned the notion that what he called the role of Adam Smith’s so-called “invisible hand” in directing market transactions (a wholly invented attribution he learned from an oral tradition in some US universities, as is often exposed on Lost Legacy, viz, there is no actual invisible hand), would be supplanted by the expected, though never realised, superior benefits of a centrally planned economy.

Lange specifically alluded to the invisible hand’s evident failures in the 1930s depression that contrasted allegedly with the far superior prospects of an harmoniously planned socialist economy, then being imposed without harmony by Stalin in Russia, and later on in Poland, in which the planners allegedly replaced the market’s ‘invisible hand’ (see his 1936. “On the Economic Theory of Socialism, Part I.” Review of Economic Studies 4, no. 1: 53–71; 1937 and Part 2, 4, no. 2: 123–142).

Paul Samuelson (Economics: an introduction to economic analysis, 1948, p 36) took up Lange’s challenge to the superiority of capitalism by recasting what Adam Smith actually wrote about ‘an invisible hand’ and invented the general rule that Smith said ‘selfish’ actions unintentionally led to ‘public benefits’, later re-cast as an early prediction of General Equilibrium theory. Unfortunately he attributed that nonsensical myth to Adam Smith, and even more unfortunately, most modern economists believe it, which Lost Legacy fights daily to challenge.

[NB: The ‘selfish’ myth actually came from Bernard Mandeville’s ‘Private Vice, Public Benefits’, Fable of the Bees, 1724 and resurrected by Ayn Rand, and broadcasted in the ‘greed is good’ libel].

In sum, Andy Logar’s pieces in the ‘American Thinker’(?) rightly critiques socialism, without really understanding the difference with capitalism, and, sadly, does not really appreciate Adam Smith’s political economy in Wealth Of Nations, nor his Theory Of Moral Sentiments.

Labels: , , , ,

Tuesday, November 08, 2011

The Cause of the Invented Version of Adam Smith's Use of the IH Metaphor

Roger Backhouse, a professor of economic history at the University of Birmingham, and Bradley W. Bateman, a professor of economics at Denison University, are the authors of “Capitalist Revolutionary: John Maynard Keynes” and write is the NY Times Sunday Review HERE

“Wanted: Worldly Philosophers”

“This wasn’t always the case. Course lists from economics departments used to be filled with offerings in “comparative economic systems,” contrasting capitalism and socialism or comparing the French, Scandinavian and Anglo-Saxon models of capitalism.

Such courses arose in the context of the cold war, when the battle with the Soviet Union was about showing that our system was better than theirs
.”

Comment
Those heady days when economics students were treated to more than passing references to the history of economic thought, sadly, are now long gone.

At Edinburgh University from the 1930s to the 1950s, economics students were treated to a syllabus that included Sir Alexander Gray’s, still fresh today, little volume, The Development of Economic Doctrine, 1931, Longman’s, London. The chapter on Adam Smith was as lucid as his lectures were reported to be even by students who never proceeded beyond first year studies. [*]

From 1948, students across the USA were introduced to Adam Smith with an innocent-looking short reference to Adam Smith’s invisible hand metaphor (Paul Samuelson's Economics: an analytical introduction, McGraw-Hill, New York). This has had calamitous unintentional consequences on economics as a discipline, and worse still, economic policies by governments whose advisors (and lobbyists) breathed in the noxious idea that an actual invisible hand operated in, variously, the ‘miracle’ of markets, close to a divine intervention by God, on the individual decision-makers in the determination of prices, supply and demand, and the providential fortunes of individuals as they exercise their self-interests.

I have explained the timing and driving dynamics that made an major error in understanding Adam Smith’s metaphor over the years by the context in which it burst across the world in Samuelson’s 20 editions of his popular textbook (c.5 million copies of the English edition, and many more similarly from its multiple translated editions) by reference to the context of the time in which McGraw-Hill picked winner.

The notion that Adam Smith meant by the metaphor of ‘an invisible hand’ gradually took its modern shape from the 1930s, after 150 years of relative and striking silence by Smith’s contemporaries, and an almost total lack of interest in the IH metaphor by political economists in the 19th-century, except for a tiny handful most of the first hundred years from Smith’s death in 1790. Only in reports of an ‘oral tradition’ at Cambridge (Pigou 1923) and also Chicago Universities, hint at some passing references (see Samuelson, 1948, p 36).

The impetus that tipped the balance was the burgeoning growth of the threat of the Soviet Union from the 1930s in what was considered to be a difficult time for capitalist economies in Europe and the Americas. Severe slumps, rising unemployment and the growth of communist and socialist parties and their ideas of a terminal collapse of capitalism put ideas of pro-market solutions under strain. Oscar Lange, a socialist academic, published his. “On the Economic Theory of Socialism, Part I and II.” 1936, Review of Economic Studies 4, no. 1: 53–71; 1937, no. 2: 123–142, which extolled the plausibility of a socialist-managed state economy, later expanded in book form in 1947. Interestingly, Lange saw the state planners as replacements for the unreliable invisible-hand of the market with their superior planning directives. Thus, from the start, the myth of the invisible hand was shrouded in myth that Smith meant it to be about a complex notion that it was about the inner-workings of markets, supply and demand dynamics, and price theories, contrary to Smith’s clearly stated notion that it was a metaphor about the consequence on the felt insecurity of some, but not all, merchants when contemplating the risks of sending their capital abroad rather than investing it in the “domestic industry”.

Samuelson, ex-Chicago, then at MIT, was writing his magnum opus, Foundations of Economic Analysis, published in 1947, quickly followed by his introductory economics textbook, published in 1948. In this introductory text, Samuelson extolled the basic soundness and superiority on the ‘mixed’ capitalist economy over a fully state-run economy of the Soviet kind. He also located Smith’s invisible hand as benefiting society as a public good, even when, or more incorrectly, particularly when the motives of individuals were ‘selfish’ (a notion never expressed by Adam Smith).

Samuelson in later editions squared his distorted interpretation of Adam Smith’ singular reference to the IH metaphor in Wealth Of Nations (from which Samuelson included a truncated quotation from the IH metaphor in paragraphs from WN (IV.ii.1-9: 456). First, Samuelson suggested that the IH metaphor had its lauded effects of delivering unintentionally a ‘public good’ only applied to a perfectly competitive economy, not an ‘imperfectly competitive’ economy, which is a serious distortion – apart from Smith never such a distinction in WN that the IH had such an effect in general.

(For an analysis of Samuelson’s changes to his incorrect original presentation for the ‘selfish’ invisible hand across edition 1 to 20 of his economics textbook, see my article in the Journal of the History of Economic Ideas, “Paul Samuelson and the Invention of the Modern Economics of the Invisible Hand”, JHEI, vol. xviii no 3, September 2010.)

Samuelson ignored the plain fact that Smith’s use of the IH metaphor applied under certain specific circumstances in the British economy, which the 18th century was anything but ‘perfectly competitive’ with its protectionist mercantile policies. In later editions Samuelson developed this ‘get out of jail’ card into wilder associations of the IH metaphor with ideas of general equilibrium economics, from the later 1950s increasingly in vogue, and with Pareto’s welfare theorem.

But recall, all of this invention of a modern IH theory/concept/ paradigm, was aimed at establishing the undoubted superiority of free(er) market economics, guided by an IH Hand, over the manifest inadequacies of dictatorial state management of the Soviet or socialist models.

This line of debate was succinctly summarised by Roger Backhouse and Bradley Bateman in their New York Times piece as arising: “in the context of the cold war, when the battle with the Soviet Union was about showing that our system was better than theirs”.

I couldn’t have put it better myself.

[*] For completeness, I draw attention to the fact that Sir Alexander Gray specifically mentions the invisible hand on six occasions in the first edition of his book, associating it with ‘miraculously harmonising’ the ‘pursuit of gain with the promotion of the public good’ (Gray, 1931, p 146). No mention, contrary to Samuelson, of anything to do with selfishness.

Labels: , ,

Friday, September 09, 2011

Gross and Imaginative Exageration

Christopher Chantril regularly writes in American Thinker (HERE):

“Invisible Hand vs. Clenched Fist”

“It's a choice that goes back 200 years, to when Adam Smith first proposed that the modern economy seemed to work like an "invisible hand" to regulate selfish behavior into socially beneficial results. We think Smith hit on something new, but he didn't. We humans do what every social animal does: help the world by helping ourselves. But it wasn't long before a rival narrative appeared -- that capitalism was a savage beast laying waste to everything it its path. It would take the clenched fist of the workers, backed up by the intelligence of an educated elite, to prevent this monster from immiserating everyone in its path, from workers to the middle class.


Ever since, the choice for moderns has been this. Do you believe in the Invisible Hand or the Clenched Fist? I'd say the choice is obvious. The Clenched Fist has failed every time it's been tried, from the French Revolution to the Bolshevik Revolution, from the New Deal to the Obama stimulus.”

Comment
I have no comments on the merits of Obama’s stimulus proposals (Lost Legacy does not comment on the politics of other countries in which I do not vote).

Christopher’s article is fairly typical of its genre – the wholesale myth of Adam Smith’s “invisible hand”, invented and perpetuated by US academe from the 1940s as part of the successful Cold War struggle against the influence of Soviet 5-year Planning propaganda. There had been an oral tradition about Adam Smith’s invisible hand metaphor from the 1920s, led by A. C. Pigou from Cambridge, England, and spread on a larger-scale by the same tradition at Chicago, USA, especially when Paul Samuelson (ex-Chicago, MIT) published his popular textbook, 5 million sales in 19 editions from 1948; his readers (6-8 million) spread all over the world. The myth is now ubiquitous in media, politics, government ministries and popular memory.

Christopher subscribes to the myth and thereby perpetuates it. Adam Smith never “proposed that the modern economy seemed to work like an 'invisible hand' to regulate selfish behavior into socially beneficial results”.

Christopher’s error is both elementary and profound. To write: “like an "invisible hand" turns the metaphor into a simile. Smith never used the “invisible hand’ as a simile, for him it was a metaphor, thereby quite different. (If you are not sure of the difference, consult a dictionary; for Smith’s deliberate meaning in using a metaphor, see his ‘Lectures in Rhetoric and Belles Letter” [1763] 1983, p 29).

Smith did not write about the IH “regulat[ing] selfish behavior into socially beneficial results”. His ‘Theory of Moral Sentiments (1759) has quite a lot to say about ‘selfishness’, none of it condoning it. The word ‘selfish’ was inserted into Paul Samuelson’s account of Smith’s use of IH and is pure invention. Moreover, Smith reference to ‘public good’ referred to the more acceptable, though narrow, point that the investment of capital in ‘domestic industry’, instead of sending it abroad at greater risk, added to “annual revenue and employment” (such as the ‘whole is the sum of its individual parts’), and this Smith regarded as a public good.

As for Christopher’s literary allusion to a “Clenched Fist”, I won’t follow that irrelevancy and grant it even negative existence. Smith lived in a mercantile state, noted for its domestic protectionism against domestic competition at every level (The Guilds, Apprentices Acts, Settlement Acts, Anti-labour Combination Acts, local Magistrates setting local wages, Primogeniture and Entail Laws) and all bolstered by national protectionism against foreign competition through tariffs and prohibitions, policed by the Navigation Acts. Britain was not a competitive environment at all.

The rest is sheer hyperbole.

Labels: ,

Sunday, August 21, 2011

From A Debate Among Historians of Economic Thought

John Womack (a contributor to a debate underway among some historians of economic thought) is closest to revealing the real problem: our graduates do not receive accurate accounts of the history of economic thought (HET), even of its major historical figures, because much of the past is presented through the lens of passing current controversies as addressed and as understood by modern authors.

This is not a new phenomenon. The ideological conflict between rising Soviet power and Western capitalist economies from the 1930s, led to the decades of the Cold War. One such apparently minor struggle in that major global competition had significant side-affects on HET, which are still with us.

Paul Samuelson wrote his canonical “Economics: an introductory Analysis” (1945-48) before achieving tenure, but felt ‘safe’ to undertake the project because of the numerous outstanding journal articles he had already published and because the invitation came from of his head of department, not the publisher, to undertake the assignment. But his knowledge of the history of economic thought in at least one area was limited to the secondary and misleading garbled (from the ‘Chinese Whispers’ affect*) Chicago oral tradition, not from his own familiarity with the original text. (My article detailing Paul Samuelson's role in these events was published in The History of Economic Ideas, 2010.)

Samuelson initiated a fatal misleading allusion that unintentionally has misled and dominated almost the entire profession since, because his famous textbook (20 editions to 2010, 5 million plus sales, numerous foreign language editions, plus a thriving secondary market) had such a mass side-effect. Readers and tutors believed what they read about this aspect of the Smith's ideas, propelled by Samuelson's deserved reputation in modern economics (Nobel Prize plus other accolades).

I refer to Samuelson’s description of Adam Smith and the “invisible hand” in Wealth Of Nations, both by a paraphrase on page 36 (1st edition), and from his various changing paraphrases of what it, supposedly, meant in the body of the textbook thereafter. These remarks were taken to extremes in associating the IH metaphor with the Welfare Theorem (A. Pigou) and General Equilibrium (Debreu), which ignores Smith's clearly stated moral stances in TMS.

Samuelson's (and presumably his tutors’) erroneous interpretation of Smith’s use of the IH metaphor in TMS and WN have dominated the beliefs of generations of graduates since the 1940s. Those beliefs are now ubiquitous, even among the majority of historians of economic thought of the highest caliber, and presumably will continue to infest the thinking of new generations of our students, current and future legislators, and those who influence them, the media the public, and the history of economic thought generally.

That is why I await publication in September of Warren Samuel’s forthcoming new book “Erasing the Invisible Hand: Essays on an Elusive and Misguided Concept in Economics”, Cambridge University Press, which was brought to completion with the assistance of Marianne Johnson, with great interest - and anticipation.

[* “Chinese Whispers’ – comes from the story of the message from a military commander that is passed on verbally through the numerous ranks to command HQ. What starts out as: “Send reinforcements we are going to advance” duly becomes garbled into “Send three and four pence we’re going to a dance”.]

Labels: ,

Sunday, August 07, 2011

Philip Pilkington On Rational Expectations Theory

Philip Pilkington writing in Irish Left Review (6 August) (HERE):
Nails the erroneous assumptions of neoclassical ‘rational expectations’ and open the way to a more accurate assessment of Adam Smith’s concept of “self-interest” (and the invisible hand).

“Neoclassical Dogma : How Economists Rationalise Their Hatred of Free Choice”

“Rational expectations is indeed an obscure doctrine. It essentially holds that people operating within a market generally act in line with the expectations of neoclassical theory. This tautology – for it is a tautology – can be traced back to Adam Smith’s ‘invisible hand’ which we explore in more detail later on.
But this goes beyond simple tautology. The neoclassical assumptions are themselves especially stringent and seem to be wholly counterfactual to any observer of human behaviour. Rational expectations theory expects people to act, well, rationally. More specifically it assumes that people always act in order to ‘maximise their utility’ and that such actions result in optimal behaviours that ensure that prices are always perfectly in keeping with what they ‘should be’ – that is, an equilibrium price that perfectly balances supply and demand. Prices then become a pristine and perfect measurement; they translate consumer desire perfectly and are beyond question
.”

Comment
Philip Pilkington is to be congratulated for asking the right questions and implying scepticism in his assertions. Neoclassical assumptions are not just contrary to the behaviours of human beings in their societies, for the record they are also contrary to how Adam Smith formulated human behaviour. The former, of course, is a more significant criticism of neoclassical rational expectations, but in so far as Adam Smith is drawn upon in support of them, as he is, we should understand this calumny imposed on his legacy.

The use of the metaphor of “an invisible hand” on two occasions in his published Works (1759, 1776) is widely interpreted to be about “markets”, “supply and demand”, and “equilibrium”. Smith made no such claims at all; that is a modern invention, made popular by Paul Samuelson in 1948. Smith never used the IH metaphor in relation to “markets”, etc., but neoclassical authors (and graduates of their courses) wrap up “invisible hands” in their assertions about “miraculous markets”.

In Moral Sentiments, Adam Smith did not restrict behaviour to “self interest” also being solely self-regarding; he also wrote of self-interest” as “other-regarding” too. In Wealth Of Nations he did this very clearly in the oft-quoted passage about persuading the famous “butcher, brewer and baker” to provide our dinners, where he specifically advises us not to “talk of our own necessities” but to address their “self-love”. In short, we serve our self-interests by serving the self-interests of others - in contrast to that nasty libel of Smith’s legacy by Gekko of ‘Wall Street’ fame. His contemporary, Mirabeau, was right: 'we think we serve ourselves by our actions, but we really serve others'.

Labels: , , ,

Thursday, August 04, 2011

Great Example of Benign and Non-Benign Self-Interest in Markets

Nicholas Gruen writes in Club Troppo (Australia) Here:

“That makes them [mortgage brokers] like computer salespeople in a department store – people who often know a lot more about the product they’re selling than their clients and able to sell from a range of brands. The good ones try very hard to inform their clients and indeed to get them the best loan possible, both because they like helping people with their skill and because in a competitive marketplace, doing the best they can do for their clients is a pretty good recipe for their own self interest (See Adam Smith, 1776 for further details).”

Comment
I am pleased to say: absolutely correct! This is an example of the correct use and reference to Adam Smith on self-interest motivating some, though unfortunately, not everybody to behave morally in a market.

Indeed, in the context in which Nick writes (follow the link) he explicitly states that other mortgage advisors in Australia do not advise their clients with complete honesty (by disclosing that they receive commissions from a select group of mortgage funders and that, in consequence, they withhold information about the other non-commissioned, perhaps better, deals more suited to their customers).

That fact shows, if such a demonstration is really necessary, that self-interest is not always socially benign from everybody in every instance. That is why indiscriminate belief in ‘an invisible hand’ is so fallacious a construction placed by modern economists (post-Samuelson) on Adam Smith’s singular use of the IH metaphor in the specific instance in which he used it in Wealth Of Nations.

Please note, especially, there is no mention by Nick Gruen of the unnecessary use of the metaphor of “an invisible hand”, which is so easily slipped in today as a (benign) general rule, such as making ‘selfish’ motives unintentionally benign (pace Gekko’s praise of ‘greed’). Yes, it's so simple - why don't modern economists get it?

[Disclosure: I have corresponded with Nick on Lost Legacy since 2005 and regard him as a sound economist. I only saw the contents of this article this morning)]

Labels: , ,

Monday, August 01, 2011

How to Mess Up an Interesting Essay

Stuart Kauffman (University of Vermont) writes an essay on utility theory (Edgworth Box diagrams, Gerald Debreu’s general equilibrium, and the Gund Institute, “value” of “bads” as opposed to “goods”) in NPR (?) (HERE):

“Current economic utility theory derives from the utilitarian ethical theories of Bentham and Mill: act for the greatest good (utility) of the greatest number. This becomes a "social welfare" function that Adam Smith's Invisible Hand was to insure.”

Comment
Modern utility theory (1870s onwards) has little to do with Adam Smith (despite Bentham’s early musings) and “social welfare” functions have even less to do with his singular use n Wealth Of Nations of the metaphor of “an invisible hand” in terms of the modern misleading and fallacious attributions of modern economists (post-Samuelson, 1948) and post-Pigovian (1923) Welfare Theorems to Adam Smith.

What is meant by stating that “Adam Smith's Invisible Hand was to insure” a “social welfare” function is a mystery beyond comprehension. Stuart Kauffman perpetuates a modern myth about Adam Smith.

Labels: , , ,

Friday, July 29, 2011

On Learning the Real Lessons of the 1930s Depression

Tom Clougherty (29 July) writes on the Adam Smith Institute Blog (HERE): a revealing and excellent account of the mythical explanations of what prolonged the Great Depression in the 1930s and what actually was its likely cause, contrary to Maynard Keynes’ widely accepted narrative in his 1936, General Theory, and in the post-war teachings of modern universities, up to the 1980s (which I, and members of the post-war university generation of economists took as gospel).

Follow the link and read Tom’s account. I have selected one paragraph from it for comment on the largely ignored side effect of the debate on Keynes’ narrative.

“Debunking the Great Depression Myth”

‘Indeed, Roosevelt was heavily influenced by his 'brains trust', which in turn was influenced by a variety of collectivist ideologies – progressivism, corporatism (of the European fascist variety), and socialism. The common theme was 'scientific' economic management by enlightened central planners, and a rejection of the free market. And, OK, perhaps that went beyond what Keynes himself would probably have advocated.”

Features of this debate are long forgotten but at the time it had some interesting side effects. People debating competing practical policies also rely on (and imply) competing theories. In the 1930s, the presence of Soviet Communism with the first of its 5-year plans’ counter-poised to capitalism, with its supposed ‘laissez-faire’ theories (though not so evident practices – tariffs, etc.,). This was the main political challenge in Europe (from the growth of communist and socialist labour parties) and in the USA (leftish Democrats v rightist Republicans), to which were added rapid military expansion into Western Europe by the Soviet Army and, in China, the seizure of power by Mao's Red Army.

Economists responded to the alleged virtues of state planning with claims for the benefits of markets and this was, perhaps, sourced from the distorting oral traditions in Cambridge, England, and Chicago, of claims for market-superiority based partly on (invented) attributions about Adam Smith’s supposed ‘invisible hand’. Oscar Lange, a Marxist economist (On the Economic Theory of Socialism, 1936 & 1938), asserted that socialist state-planning was a substitute for the market's invisible hand and claimed that socialism would do much better in directing the economy to its most productive uses than the unreliable and uncertain invisible hand:

“The market has, therefore, been compared to that of an invisible hand which produces co-ordination out of the autonomous decisions of many separate units. Not all markets, however, are able to produce such coordination, nor is the coordination obtained always consistent with accepted social objectives. In such cases, planning is used to either reach the co-ordination, otherwise unobtainable or to correct the co-ordination produced by the invisible hand of the market” (Lange 1945, 26).

Paul Samuelson, while an undergraduate at Chicago, was taught that the invented ‘invisible hand’ theory belonged to Adam Smith, and in his famous and popular textbook (Economics: an introductory analysis, 1948, p 36) responded implicitly to the challenge of socialist planning by placing Smith’s alleged theory of the invisible hand as relevant only to a purely laissez-faire economy but not to a post-war mixed capitalist economy. This perpetuated a myth about Adam Smith (he never saw the metaphor of an invisible hand as connected to markets), but the belief that he did, became (and still is) ubiquitous.

It helped cement Keynes’ narrative of the Great `Depression’ – he referred to the alternatives of democratic governments’ demand management as an alternative to laissez-faire, classical 'do nothing' policies that allegedly were believed and advocated by ‘classical’ economics as best way to respond to crises. Keynes created a narrative of the causes of the 1930s depression that is now widely accepted along with its (not Smith’s) failures of ‘an invisible hand’, which is heard often in today’s debates on the current recession. Some politicians that it was the alleged absence of 'regulation' and state intervention –and a belief in 'laissez-faire' - that led to these crises in the first place and they advocate, instead, more regulations and more state stimulation by ‘quantative easing’, ‘subsidies’ and even ‘more borrowing’ (after the state’s credit cards are already ‘maxed out’!).

As the real lessons of the 1930s depression have not featured much in today's debate (and Tom Cougherty post is an excellent place to start) it might help clarify what is needed by paying close attention to it.

[Disclosure: I am a Fellow of the Adam Smith Institute.]

Labels: , , ,

Saturday, July 23, 2011

History of the Myth of the Invisible Hand

Over lunch at the Bank of England [in April, 1946, just days before Maynard died], Keynes is claimed to have told Henry Clay (a professor of Social Economics and Advisor to the Bank of England) of his hopes that Adams Smith's "invisible hand" can help Britain out of the economic hole it was in after the Second World War with a near-exhausted British economy, deeply in debt to the USA:

"I find myself more and more relying for a solution of our problems on the invisible hand which I tried to eject from economic thinking twenty years ago."

Comment
This one of those unverifiable statements attributed to Keynes, interesting in itself, and also for what it leaves unsaid about the history of this modern myth of 'an invisible hand'.

But of more interest historically, it is some confirmation of the existence of an oral tradition at Cambridge University that articulated ideas about the meaning Smith was supposed to have attributed to his use of the ‘invisible hand’ metaphor. Sometime, since Alfred Marshall dominated economic teaching in British universities and A.C. Pigou, his immediate heir, had carried on in his teachings, and, in his case, had published the same ideas from the oral tradition in his early editions of Welfare Economics – largely to undermine the ‘invisible hand’ of the economy with his academic case for the government using intervention by taxation to achieve welfare objectives that were allegedly immune to the beneficial activities of ‘an invisible hand’.

The oral tradition was necessarily an heavily massaged version of Adam Smith’s limited usage of the metaphor (only twice in all his published writings) and in no way did Smith use it in reference to the workings of markets. The assertions of Henry Clay in 1946 mark the mid 1920s as when Keynes said he had "tried had to eject [the IH metaphor] from economic”.

This is in line with Paul Samuelson’s claim that he had heard the oral case linked to Adam Smith, at Chicago when he was an undergraduate there in the early 1930s, which fits the similar use of the ‘invisible hand’ by Oscar Lange (a Marxist) as a feature of capitalist economies (in his The Economic Theory of Socialism 1936 and 1938). In these publications, Lange saw the community state substituting planning for the so-called "invisible hand'.

To Paul Samuelson goes the dubious honour of popularising these myths of “Adam Smith’s invisible hand” across US academe through the 20 editions of his successful textbook, Economics: an introductory analysis (McGraw-Hill) 1948 (2010).

It is in the nature of oral traditions to leave no traces of them and they die out with the passing of the perpetrators – and it is only when oral assertions and pass into print (or, today, online) that we pick up hard evidence.

It is remarkable that only a few economists either drew attention to the oral tradition of the (mis)use of the IH metaphor or integrated the myths into their own works until the explosion of mentions of the myth began to appear in the decades following Samuelson’s references to it. Now it is ubiquitous, and in too many case also plain silly ('the invisible hand kicking people in the behind', etc.,).

Certainly, few, if any (I would say ‘none’ did, but you never know if something may turn up – and Lost Legacy readers are always a useful source of snippets that I will follow if any emerge), of Smith’s contemporaries considered the IH metaphor of any importance or relevant to Smith’s works, and precious few – a handful, not all of them economists – ever mentioned Adam Smith and the metaphor until the late 19th century and the beginning of the 20th century.

My searc continues.

Labels: , , ,

Monday, March 14, 2011

A Market Oracle Miss-Speaks

Garry North wrtes in The Market Oracle Blog (HERE)

“Because the Lord helps those who help themselves, the hard-working person is seen as part of a productive economy. This economy rests on the combination of God's providence and hard work. While Adam Smith's famous invisible hand persuaded some intellectuals for a century or so, 1776–1875, the general public assumed that there really is an invisible hand guiding the process of productivity. This legitimized every man's labor.”

Comment
Gary North is quite mistaken. The period from 1776 when Adam Smith used the invisible hand metaphor (IH metaphor) in Wealth Of Nations (only once, though he had also used it before (once only) in Moral Sentiments in 1759), to a century later in 1875, is distinguished by the fact that hardly anybody – intellectuals, ‘famous’ or otherwise – referred to it. We know this because I have challenged several dedicated scholars (of impeccable reputations as intellectuals) to list them and the result has been pathetically few.

They have singularly failed to discover more than a small handful – in fact two only between 1776 and 1856 – and a few in the period confined to the 1780s – 1900. The IH metaphor appeared in the oral tradition at Cambridge (UK) and a few lecturers at Chicago (USA) (according to Paul Samuelson when he was an undergraduate there), but the IH metaphor seldom appeared in print in economics texts or journal articles (but see two prominent examples: Arthur Pigou’s Welfare Economics,1922 and, Alexander Grey’s 1930 text, The Development of Economic Doctrine) until the post-war decades, primarily following Paul Samuelson’s wildly successful Economics: an introductory Analysis (1948 and the 19 editions to 2010).

What Garry North means by the “the general public assumed that there really is an invisible hand guiding the process of productivity”, or when they assumed this is not clear, but if he refers to the period 1776-1875 (or even the period 1875-1960) he is quite wrong.

However, after Oscar Lange (1938 and 1947) and Paul Samuelson (1948) introduced the IH metaphor – labeling it as Adam Smith’s ‘famous’ metaphor – and their works, particularly Samuelson’s – which reached a widespread public as a popular Economics 101 (and Economics 101-plus) university text – which was copied as Adam Smith's metaphor into hundreds of other author's texts, and then, as the millions of graduates spread out into public life, the media, and across the world, so the IH metaphor acquired traction in popular public discourse.

[To sample the modern phenomena of the ubiquitous IH metaphor, take ‘Google Alerts’ for a week or two …]

Gary North might care to rethink his assertion in The Market Oracle.

Labels: , ,

Saturday, February 12, 2011

Once More With Feeling...

Writing in the “Ultra-Bourgeoisiology” Blog (HERE):

“Smith appears to make some questionable assumptions in offering the theory of the invisible hand. The following passage encapsulates the problem:

'Every individual is continually exerting himself to find out the most advantageous employment for whatever capital he can command. It is his own advantage, indeed, and not that of the society, which he has in view. But the study of his own advantage naturally, or rather necessarily, leads him to prefer that employment which is most advantageous to the society.' (IV.2.4)

Assuming, however, that individuals are nonetheless predominately motivated by the particular configuration of self-interest that Smith has in mind, it is unclear whether the “society” to which advantage accrues is necessarily the immediate and “entire” society to which the individual belongs. It seems quite plausible that the benefits thus obtained might be concentrated in very few hands within a society. Do these beneficiaries represent the interests of society in general? Smith clearly privileges the total sum of “benefits,” but in this case there seems to be some ambiguity in the meaning of “benefit,” especially when some elements within society may actually experience substantial “losses” in the process.

… If Smith is right that society receives the greatest benefit even when every individual works to advance his own advantage, and if such a theory informs this egocentric modality, it seems that maximizing the public good is precisely the goal—why must it be hidden?”


Comment
I made the following comments on the Ultra-Bourgeoisiology” Blog:

“Adam Smith did not have a "theory" of "an invisible hand". That was an idea invented by modern economists from the 1950s. Smith used '"an invisible hand" as a metaphor in Wealth Of Nations (Book IV, chapter 2, p 456) for some, but not all, merchants, who were concerned with the security of trading with foreign countries or the colonies, and, therefore, preferred to trade "domestically".

It was their concern for their own security that 'led them' to invest in "domestick" industry, which Smith correctly noted added to "domestick annual revenue and employment" - a purely limited arithmetic outcome (the whole is the sum of its parts) - which Smith believed was a public benefit. The idea that this was a general benefit across all participants to the same degree was invented by, among others, Paul Samuelson in his Economics text, 1948, p 36, and in theories of General Equilibrium.
The author quoted a few lines from paragraph 9 and missed the particular and limited meaning Smith gave to it, as well as ignored the previous 8 paragraphs in which Smith makes clear his meaning. Metaphors express "in a more striking and interesting manner" their "objects" (see Adam Smith's own "Lectures in Rhetoric and Belles Lettres" [1763] 1983, p 29.”

I should have added that market prices are not invisible – it evident that they are very visible – and the metaphor cannot therefore refer to a “theory of markets”. The relative insecurity of market participants is invisible, which, on this occasion, is the object of the metaphor.

Labels: , ,

Thursday, February 03, 2011

Better to be Mostly Right Than Mostly Wrong (2)

[In the Comments to ‘Being Mostly Right is Better Than Being Mostly Wrong’ (yesterday), Jacob Levy questions my assertions about Smith’s meaning in using the Invisible Hand metaphor and I respond as below.

First, Jacob’s comment.]

Jacob Levy:

“While you seem to have dug much more deeply into this than I have, I have doubts about your late dating of the spread of "invisible hand" as a shorthand for Smith's economic thought, or of its use out of proportion to the importance the metaphor actually had for Smith. I have open in front of me F.W Maitland's A Historical Sktech of Liberty and Equality, 1875, pp. 130-31, which treats it as already the general received wisdom that "invisible hand" and "natural harmony of economic interests" are the same idea, and takes the trouble to show that Smith's belief in them was more limited than was (already, in 1875) widely believed.”

And my (long) response:

“Your thoughts on the importance to Adam Smith of his use of the metaphor of an invisible hand are challenging; they are not, in my view decisive. That F. W. Maitland (1850-1906), as a professor of the laws of England at the University of Cambridge, wrote about Adam Smith’s use of the invisible hand metaphor (IH metaphor), he reflects what is known of the existence Cambridge oral tradition (delivered in lectures and tutorials, rather than in print, which while interesting as a reflection of that oral tradition, they do not demonstrate that the oral tradition expressed Adam Smith’s meaning (Maitland’s ‘Historical Sketch’ is available from Liberty Fund)
.
The influence of Maitland, and a handful of others from the 1870s, was not comparable with the far more decisive explosion in daily references to the IH metaphor in its modern forms from the 1950s. This new 20th-century phenomenon started in the economics discipline after Paul Samuelson’s highly successful and ground-breaking Econ 101 textbook, Economics: an introductory analysis (1948), and took-off over its 19 editions. A wide spectrum of graduate economists, plus those many ‘one-semester only’ readers, took the IH metaphor to their campuses and professional work on a scale wondrous to behold – to sample this phenomenon, read for a week-or-two the free, daily ‘Google Alerts’ for ‘Invisible Hand’ in the world’s media each morning on your PC.

As Samuelson put it, his and earlier, generations, took:

‘This unguarded conclusion [“the mystical principle of the “invisible hand”] has done almost as much harm as good in the past century and a half, especially since too often it is all that some of our leading citizens remember, 30 years later, of their college course in economics (Economics, 1948, p 36)’.

Today, the IH metaphor is ubiquitous, and like a virus (simile) has spread well beyond the millions of attendees at a ‘college course in economics’. It has recently become more controversial, too. Stigler announced recently that ‘it does not exist’, and while encouraging, he was not for the ‘right’ reasons. Also the current the ‘anti-market’ tone of the questioning is disappointing, but so is the failure to realise that Adam Smith made no explicit references to the IH metaphor being a metaphor for markets (nor for perfect competition, the welfare theorems, or general equilibrium). For Smith it was a metaphor and is to be read as such, and the object of the metaphor in his use of it clearly stated when and where he used it.

Smith’s use of the IH metaphor, in contrast, was hardly mentioned until long after he died in 1790. Dugald Stewart, his close family-friend, used Wealth of Nations as the supporting text in his Lectures on Political Economy, delivered at the University of Edinburgh, from 1801. When his lectures were published in the 1850s, they included, in extensive footnote form, extracts from Wealth Of Nations. The IH metaphor passage is among these extracts, but is not commentated on in the lectures as significant. Nor do Smith’s critics in the 1800s mention it; Ricardo’s ‘Principles’ does not discuss it, and I have found no reference to it in Mill or Marx (factual corrections always welcome).

The few references, post-Maitland (1875) certainly show that the IH metaphor was around and understood as you suggest. But so was the alleged doctrine of ‘Adam Smith’s laissez-faire’, the roots of which were closer to Manchester School ideology (pressed on behalf of the mill and mine owners in the legislature) than Smith’s critique of mercantile political economy, which did not mention laissez-faire, nor the other assertions which your article correctly identifies (hence, my point about it being ‘Better to be Mainly Right’, which you are in respect of the bulk of your article).

A. C. Pigou mentions the IH hand metaphor in his welfare economics lectures and text and points to the deficiencies of competition in respect of disagreeable externalities, which, he argued, require, correction by government taxes or subsidies. Others, for example, Alexander Grey in Edinburgh, who included the IH metaphor in his excellent History of Economics (1931, Longmans) when discussing Adam Smith; he placed a theological gloss on it. Oscar Lange, a Marxist, appropriated the Chicago oral tradition (alluded to by Samuelson, above) in 1938 and 1946, to incorporate the IH metaphor in his socialist economics as a task best left to socialist planners because of ‘market failures’ (a more authoritarian response than Pigou’s).

Now, what none of these authors, nor those who quote them with relief – as if secondary sources are definitive and are articulate what Adam Smith meant when he used it (I draw this conclusion with many debates in Lost Legacy with articulate and civilized exponents such as Daniel Klein and David Freidman). They reject my references to Smith on the use of metaphors (he was a long-standing lecturer on Rhetoric in Edinburgh, 1748-51, and in Glasgow 1752-64; we have student notes of his Lectures on Rhetoric and Belles Lettres’ [1762-3]). Klein and Freidman reject the critical key to Smith’s meaning – what was the object of the IH metaphor as he used it, not how they attribute it to him?

All references to wider meanings about ‘markets, prices, and systemic harmony’ are imputed, often by modern concepts of which Smith and his readers were unfamiliar, and by allusions to which he was, if anything, and certainly in the modern contexts claimed, hostile – such as ‘selfishness’ being overcome by it.

Markets operate, not by a ‘magical’, nor theological, invisible hand, but by a very visible price system, clearly delineated by Adam Smith in Books I and II of Wealth Of Nations – the dynamic supplied by the very visible (in Smith’s terminology) relationship of ‘natural’ prices and ‘market’ prices – the former based on costs, of which the producer is well aware and respectful – it’s his money; the latter based on variable effectual demand in the market each day, on which his profit – and survival – may depend. If he covers his costs (inclusive of his profit) he continues; if he doesn’t he adjusts his behaviour as quickly as he can. He is not ‘led’ by ‘an invisible hand’ to do this. The driver is very visible, not invisible, because in market prices have to be visible for buyers and sellers to enter into and conclude exchange transactions. They must address each others’ self-interests, not just their own.

The ‘invisible hand’ metaphor refers to what cannot be seen, such as the private motivations of the parties. To assume and assert that it is merely about global ‘self-interest’ that drives them is empty of explanation (no mathematical terms exists for the IH in all the equations). Smith makes this point well in Wealth of Nations.

The merchant’s self-interest may be to make a profit (he can’t make one if he suffers losses), but to make a profit he has to take risks when undertaking the costs of producing his items for sale. Risks are not equal or certain in all activities; some activities may be perceived more risky than others. The security of his capital outlays is important (in the 18th century, utter destitution awaited losers). If an activity is associated with higher risks than another that is available, some, but not all, merchants tend to avoid the more risky venture if they can.

In Smith’s sole example in Wealth Of Nations, some merchants are influenced to avoid foreign and colonial trades and prefer to trade locally. Smith details the reasons of their insecurity for this in the paragraphs preceding his use of IH metaphor and specifically states why they prefer to invest in ‘domestick’ trade. By thus avoiding their perceived risks of foreign trade, they are led to add to the only alternative of ‘domestick’ investment, which adds to the annual output of ‘necessaries and conveniences’. Only arithmetic is required to understand this – he was writing for legislators and those of who influenced them, not maths graduates, like himself, and we call that rule: the ‘whole is the sum of its parts’. Wealth consisted of the ‘annual revenue and employment’ from the ‘conveniences, necessaries, and conveniences of life’.

I venture to suggest that his mostly educated readers would likely have studied classical languages, English and rhetoric too, and they would be familiar with the role of a metaphor: to connect to its object, and to express it in a “more striking and interesting manner” (Smith: Lectures on Rhetoric and Belles Lettres, [1762-3) Liberty Fund, p 29). Yes – that’s all!
I would further suggest that the invisible hand was a very common figure of speech as a metaphor in the 17th-18th century, mainly in theology, sermons, and literature. Many before and after Smith used the same metaphor in scores of context. He did not invent it. He simply stated its object, as his students and educated readers would expect. The main reason why his contemporaries made nothing of Smith’s use of the IH metaphor, is simply because they could see what he was doing, and saw him use many other metaphors, some memorable (‘Daedalian wings of paper money’) and some execrable (‘waggon-way through the air’ (WN II.ii.p 321).

Practical business people today know they can see how markets work by the very visible instrument of prices. They do not need ‘an invisible hand’ to do that.

To paraphrase a Hollywood scriptwriter: “Show me the price! And only then I may decide whether to give you the money”.

Gavin"

Labels: ,

Monday, January 31, 2011

Being Mostly Right Is Better Than Being Mostly Wrong

In today’s “Article Cube” (HERE):

“Is free market capitalism actually practiced in the United States today still alive or is it now just a product of our imagination?

Let’s analyze the facts and see for ourselves.

Americans have traditionally believed that the "invisible hand of the market" means that capitalism will benefit us all without requiring any oversight. However, the man (i.e. Adam Smith) who came up with the idea of the invisible hand did not believe in a magically benevolent market which operates for the benefit of all without any checks and balances:

Smith railed against monopolies and the political influence that accompanies economic power...

Smith worried about the encroachment of government on economic activity, but his concerns were directed at least as much toward parish councils, church wardens, big corporations, guilds and religious institutions as to the national government; these institutions were part and parcel of 18th-century government...

Smith was sometimes tolerant of government intervention, 'especially when the object is to reduce poverty. Smith passionately argued, ''When the regulation, therefore, is in support of the workman, it is always just and equitable; but it is sometimes otherwise when in favor of the masters.'' He saw a tacit conspiracy on the part of employers ''always and everywhere'' to keep wages as low as possible.

Yes….Adam Smith may have been the father of free-market economics, but he argued that bank regulation was as necessary as fire codes on urban buildings, and called for a ban on high-risk, high-interest lending, the 18th-century version of subprime.
”

Comment
The article is mostly right about Smith – clearly its author has read Wealth Of Nations and is welcome for that and is worthy of congratulations for getting Adam Smith so right.

The muddle about the invisible hand is unfortunate, so I would add my remarks below.

It wasn't Smith who was wrong about his use (only once in Wealth of Nations) of the invisible hand metaphor; those modern economists were wrong who attributed to him an invisible hand that applied to markets. This is myth.

Smith did not hold that the invisible hand guided or operated in markets; he used in a different context.

Among the first to assert the popular modern view of the metaphor was Paul Samuelson in his text-book, Economics (1948), from which all the 'beneficial' affects flowed. But, even Samuelson had to modify his claims in later editions.

For Smith, some merchants, but not all, avoided foreign and colonial trade because of the higher risks involved, therefore, they invested domestically instead, thus adding to domestic 'annual revenue and employment'. This arithmetic consequence had nothing to do with general equilibrium or the welfare theorems. Rama Cont should identify the real cultprit, Samuelson - Adam Smith was right; his claims were much more modest in that the whole is the sum of its parts.

Labels: ,

Wednesday, January 19, 2011

Using the Invisible-Hand Myth to Bash Markets

Charles Sullivan writes in Bear Market News Blog (HERE) (from something in the Guardian UK newspaper):

“Capitalism, Market Fundamentalism, and the Duplicitous Meanings of Democracy”

“Private ownership of the means of production and the invisible hand of the market are two key components of modern capitalism. In reality, there is no ‘invisible hand’ of the market, as the proponents of free market capitalism contend. If there were, the global banking system would have collapsed long ago. We have only to lift the cloak of secrecy for the human fingerprints of manipulation to become plainly visible. A small cadre of the elite is manipulating everything.”

Comment
This is from a leftish Blog that believes the ‘ruling class’ runs everything, so it is not exactly a recantation from those responsible among academic economists for the myth of ‘an invisible hand’, leading even ‘selfish’ capitalists and as selfish consumers to the wonderful miracle of benefitting society, and to the even more miraculous outcome of perfect harmony between what suppliers supply and consumers want to consume.

The Left does not believe in the invisible hand (at least not since Oscar Lange tried to adopt the idea (circulating in Chicago in the 1930s) in 1938 and 1946 that it was something claimed by Adam Smith for free markets (It wasn’t, but that’s another and longer story), which in Lange’s view could be better performed by socialist planning in the Soviet Union, and in post-war Poland, later taken over by the Red Army.

This was followed by a staunch, rival claim from Paul Samuelson (of Chicago and MIT) in 1948 that the ‘invisible hand’ was Adam Smith’s “central idea”, applicable to perfect-market economies and, later, allegedly proved by Arrow and Debreu in advanced General Equilibrium mathematics.

Since then, the myth of Adam Smith’s ‘invisible hand’ has spread like a meme into the unthinking intellectual apparatus of graduate economists and the media/political/lobbying hordes who pass for informed opinion.

That the invisible-hand does not exist is not disputed on Lost Legacy. It never existed, and Smith’s use of the metaphor had nothing to do with what the post-late 1870s academics made of it.

That the invisible-hand had anything to do with the current crisis in state-managed capitalist economies is disputed. Metaphors do not have operational roles in the real world. Asserting that they do, literally is nonsense and an ideological alibi, in Bear Market News, to bash markets.

Labels: , ,

Monday, January 03, 2011

Free Thinkers Can Be Wrong Too

Jon Lindgren posts (3 January) in Red River Freethinkers (‘the truth will set you free’) HERE

“What is the “Common Good”?

“Those two words are simply beautiful. What do they mean? Surely, one part of the definition is that the common good is the opposite of selfishness. But, even that is not quite so clear. In 1776, Adam Smith published The Wealth of Nations which pointed out that in a capitalistic, everyone seeking their own selfish ends works to serve the common good by producing the goods we want the most. Other people argue that a socialistic democracy is better at seeking the common good because we can elect people who will then use a country’s resources to pursue this noble end
.”

Comment
It is essential for constructive debate to ensure that assertions about a person’s statements are correct. Jon Lindgren asserts that Adam Smith pointed out that “everyone seeking their own selfish ends works to serve the common good by producing the goods we want the most.”

I am entitled to ask where Adam Smith made such a statement? He implies that it is to be found in Wealth Of Nations, but where exactly? He never said – and I challenge Jon Lindgren to produce his evidence – that everyone seeks “their own selfish ends” or that commerce – he never used the word “capitalistic” – would have the power which he ascribes to it.

Jon Lindgren
, or more likely his source for this misleading statement, confuses Adam Smith with Bernard Mandeville’s ‘Fable of the Bees’ (1724) with Smith’s Wealth Of Nations published 52 years later. Mandeville was responsible for creating a philosophy out of selfishness – “Private Vices, Public Benefits”, which Smith regarded, and wrote so in his Theory of Moral Sentiments (1759), as an unqualified “licentious” philosophy.

In fact, the most that anyone could draw from Smith’s view of “self-interest” of people unintentionally working for the common good in the single paragraph where he mentions the ‘invisible hand’ in Wealth Of Nations, is that by adding their annual revenue and employment to that of the rest of the society’s annual revenue and employment, it would increase the total of it – the whole is the sum of its parts – without making any statement about the nature of the consequential distribution of total output.

That it benefitted society came much later in the 20th century, following Paul Samuleson, and others, in his “Economic: an analytical introduction”, McGraw-Hill, 1948, page 36.

Smith regarded the actions of “merchants and manufacturers” with studied suspicion and showed how they did not work for the best of society in the main, with their mercantile monopolies, tariffs, prohibitions and influence on the legislature.

That is: the opposite of what Jon Lindgren (and for that matter, Paul Samuelson) asserted he did. Jon's in good company, but completely wrong for all that.

Labels: ,

Wednesday, December 29, 2010

Joseph Stiglitz Repudiates the Invisible Hand, but Accepts the Myth of Adam Smith's Culpability in Promoting It

A short video of Joseph Stiglitz declaiming the modern version of Adam Smith’s alleged ‘doctrine’ of the ‘invisible hand’ is available HERE

‘Joseph Stiglitz Against Adam Smith's Invisible Hand’

“Nobel Prize winner Joseph Stiglitz challenges the influential teachings of 18th-century economist Adam Smith, citing flaws with Smith's metaphor of an "invisible hand" guiding the free market. "The reason the invisible hand often seemed invisible was that it wasn't there," he says. Stiglitz claims an uncritical adherence to Smith's ideas is partially to blame for the current financial crisis
.”

Comment
Stiglitz’s declamation takes the view that the modern teaching of “almost every graduate school in the country’ is wrong, because the ‘invisible hand’ is ‘not there’, which leaves Adam Smith lumbered with what was a modern invention (see Paul Samuelson, Economics: an introductory analysis, p 36, McGraw-Hill, 1948) that is not supported by the Smith’s texts, not just by a nuance, but by being quire contrary to anything Smith wrote.

Stiglitz argues that the claim that modern markets do not support the modern assertions and the evidence exposes the fallacy that they do, and yet he still lumbers Adam Smith with the authority for the claims made in his name.

The fact is, Adam Smith is wholly innocent. That he was ‘wrong’ in some way is a ludicrous claim; the guilty parties are all those lemming-like economists who repeat the charge of Smith’s “error”, but who have never bothered to read Adam Smith’s use of the metaphor of an invisible hand on the three occasions only that he used it. In none of these uses was he referring to anything remotely related to ‘perfect competition’. The edifice collapses on the evidence, yet very bright minds believe the contrary.

He referred in Astronomy to credulous Romans who believed that the God Jupiter fired thunder bolts in his anger (Smith called it ‘pusillanimous superstition’; In Moral Sentiments he referred to rich warlord/feudal landowners, not markets, and in Wealth Of Nations he referred to some, but not all, merchants in mercantile Britain, who preferred the relative ‘safety’ of a tariff-ridden, outright prohibitionist, mercantile monopoly of Guilds, the Apprentice Statutes, the Settlement Acts, and Chartered-venturer Britain to risking their capital abroad (protected by the Navigation Acts, policed by the Royal Navy) .

If you could ever get further from competitive markets, I cannot think of what it would look like, short of total State communism. And despite all this, modern economists read into Smith the 'First Welfare Theorem' and 'General Equilibrium'!

Not since astrology and alchemy ran through and alongside natural science has a discipline claiming to be science (in this case modern economics) promoted such a crass error and called it scientific.

Labels: , ,