Monday, September 26, 2011

From The Adam Smith Institute Post on Panmure House

The restoration of Panmure House by Dr Eamonn Butler (25 September 2011)

"The plan to restore Adam Smith's old home in Edinburgh, Panmure House, is now getting underway in earnest. The only one of Smith's lifetime homes still standing, he resided there for the last nine years of his life, and held literary salons every Sunday when he would invite some of the leading intellectuals of the Scottish Enlightenment round to discuss ideas. Now the Edinburgh Business School at Heriot Watt University has bought the house to save it for future generations, and return to this tradition, creating an elegant space for meetings, debates and the arts.

It is not an easy job. It has taken three years (!) to get planning approval for the restoration. And sadly, this fine eighteenth-century townhouse is in a dangerous condition, reduced to a sorry state by three decades of local-authority occupation, as these pictures of the inside show (not shown here; see the pictures on the original post at Adam Smith Blog HERE: When restored, the same rooms (also pictured) will be quite magnificent. Work starts in March.

This week a fundraising panel at the Edinburgh Business School started work on raising the £5m needed to restore the house and keep it running, in use and indeed loved. If you would like to help this effort – or indeed contribute financially to the work of breathing life into Adam Smith's too-long-neglected him, do let me know: eamonn.butler@adamsmith.org"

Labels:

Thursday, July 21, 2011

REPAIR AND RENOVATION OF ADAM SMITH’S PANMURE HOUSE APPROVED! (at last)

It has just been announced (11.30 am this morning!) that the Scottish Government has approved the proposals from Edinburgh Business School (Heriot-Watt University) for the sympathetic renovation of ‘Panmure House’, just off old Edinburgh’s historic Royal Mile, where Adam Smith lived from 1778 up to his death in 1790.

The planning authorities have at last given the go ahead, despite objections from ‘Historic Scotland’, a statutory publicly-funded body (forcing a public inquiry), into the important features necessary in EBS plans both to comply with current legal requirements for public access (wheel-chair access, fire exits, and public toilets) and to allow the old building (1697) to be suitable for its educational and research purposes, and to preserve it historic character as Adam Smith's house.

This is an example of public legal regulations having expensive and frustrating consequences for a market-funded Business School's attempt to meet them in the most sympathetic way, being disputed by another publicly-funded body, forcing long delays until the Scottish Government made its final decision, all of which objection and inquiry work was funded by the taxpayer (excepting the work and cost of the delay and inquiry to the non-state financed Edinburgh Business School) .

EBS proposed to construct an imaginative glass atrium to the original rear of Panmure House, to allow compliance with the standard regulations requiring the provision for access for wheel-chairs, fire regulations, and to modernise the toilet provision inside the building. The problem was that providing for these desirable (and legal) facilities within the confined space of a 16th-century building, as insisted by Historic Scotland, was not possible without enabling safe access to the upper floor for people from outside the building. This was why EBS proposed a solution involving an attractive glass atrium to provide both for safe access and exit by all visitors, including a lift for those in wheel chairs, while leaving the original stone walls completely visible without damage to the original fabric, to leave adequate useable space inside Panmure House. Historic Scotland disagreed and forced a pubic inquiry.

With today's planning approvals, EBS can now commence to put its ambitious plans into action. The architects can detail their drawings, the funds can now be mobilised from generous donors around the world, and everything prepared for Panmure House to become, not just a (welcome) magnet for visitors to Edinburgh, but also for its serious academic and educational work to commence (at no cost to the public purse).

Gavin Kennedy (Emeritus Professor, Heriot-Watt University, Edinburgh)

Labels:

Friday, March 04, 2011

Adam Smith’s Panmure House Public Inquiry (2nd and 3rd March)

I sat through the 2 full-days of the Panmure House Inquiry – the only person in the public seats who did so, out of the dozen or so others who attended for parts of the time, sharing the toil of the official attendees - 14 officials and the Reporter – who were compelled to endure the long hours of laborious testimony and procedure.

For this quasi-judicial exercise; the Reporter sits at the head of a ‘v’-shaped pyramid table-setting, with the parties for and against sitting opposite each other, and about a couple of dozen members of the public and the press, sitting in two rows of chairs forming the pyramid’s base.

For those brought-up on TV diet of US Court-room dramas, this was a very mild and typically Scottish affair, following a staid legal process (no ‘objections’ allowed, or called, no histrionics, no badgering witnesses, no ‘judges’ calling opposing counsel to order, and no ‘last minute’ surprises). Counsel for both sides led their witnesses (who, like them were sitting down throughout) through the reading of their prior-written evidence, followed by close questioning by the other side’s legal counsel of the details of their evidence. The papers relating to the Inquiry were in several six-inch thick ring-binders, requiring the witnesses and the officials to take the time to find the relevant documents and read the relevant subject (a process often taking time to execute, with regular delays while some documents were re-sorted and re-ordered, or, in a few case, ‘borrowed' from their opposing counsel).

I thought more than once, that this polite and patient behaviour was conducive to less pressure than a viva some PhDs candidates experience. It was very polite and indulgent, and conducive to getting at facts rather making for entertainment.

The witnesses for EBS explained why it had proposed to erect a glass-atrium at Panmure House in between the arms of the surviving ‘L’ shaped building (it used to be 'T' shaped) to contain a glass circular stairway to the first and second floors, instead of using a existing stairs (built in 1955) inside the house. The recent - and thereby current – legal regulations for access to new and renovated buildings require accessibility for disabled persons and this requires larger turning-space for wheel chairs on each floor of Panmure House. Other regulations for public use require male and female toilets (not a consideration either in Adam Smith’s time, or when the house had been ‘renovated’, otherwise internally wrecked by Edinburgh City Council for a ‘troublesome’ youths’ Club in the 1970s).

As an EBS Education Centre it requires the highest standard of internal fittings and fixtures with the toilets sited on each floor, which would not be possible if internal stairs, plus disabled access, was installed; hence, the external stairs in the atrium, and a lift for proper disable access, with the requirement for the same entry and floor access as other visitors. The suggestion given by Scottish Heritage was for all toilets to be located in the basement, this discriminating against everybody having to descend through two floors and more than awkward for receptions for over 20 people or larger audiences at lectures and seminars.

The objectors were from Scottish Heritage, the World Heritage committee, the Edinburgh Council Planning Officials, and the Old Town Conservation people – most of them fulltime officials, well paid for and funded by the taxpayer. Supporting the EBS plans were the elected representatives of Edinburgh City Council (the spokesman for the City Council was the Convenor of the Planning Committee, and local home owners association). The Convenor was an experienced elected representative, who knew as much about the planning regulations and procedures as the Scottish Heritage full-time paid witnesses, and had been party to many planning decisions over years of long service.

The main case against EBS’s plans was that the glass atrium would have an ‘adverse effect on Panmure House, as a 17th-century ‘Grand Town House, though it was no longer set in ‘handsome gardens’ or a grand area. Indeed, immediately opposite Panmure House is a dilapidates warehouse, next to some modern deteriorating flats (apartments), and a major 1960s council- owned development that is more than a bit of an eyesore. The original entrance to Panmure House, through Panmure Close, is via a locked iron gate, and some recently built residences surrounded by high walls. Panmure House is now approached through a 1960’s archway in Loch End Close, which nearby buildings and walls intrude on visitors’ views of it. Moreover, all the internal panelled walls, floors and original main-door entrance are now gone and only the outside wall remains. The roof is in a parlous state and needs early, if not immediate, repair and attention to avoid it collapse into the building.

EBS plans to restore the original roof and replace the current narrow entrance (it was ‘converted’ poorly in the 1960s from an original window space) with a new one on the basement-level floor. The glass atrium would rise from this level to below the current roof-line; the dilapidated and now rusty guttering would be replaced with glass guttering. The atrium construction allows for total see-through from the street to the original 17th century and (newly cleaned) stonework. It will be a striking enhancement of the original architectural heritage and contrast with the slum-like nearby buildings built in the 19th and 20th centuries.

The main aspect of Panmure House is its association with Adam Smith and the other luminaries of the Scottish Enlightenment who lived, or visited it, which gives it its ‘special national and international historical merit’ – a main leal criterion of a building’s claim to be a heritage site worthy of conserving in the legislation.

A Scottish Heritage official giving evidence against the EBS case claimed that while acknowledging the historical importance of Adam Smith to Panmure’s significance, she also claimed – to the astonishment of the officials and supporters of EBS’s proposals - that the conservation undertaken from the 1950’s (including the deplorable destruction of Panmure’s remaining internal features) was now also part of Panmure’s heritage (even the Reporter queried what she had asserted and noted her affirmative confirmation!). For myself, I was astonished at such nonsense – that it is a necessary part of Panmure’s history (it happened, yes) it was certainly not any part of Panmures ‘heritage’ worthy of saving. Which is what heritage and conservation are all about, certainly to people not employed by Scottish Heritage.

The object of a public inquiry for the opposing parties is to persuade and convince the Reporter, who deliberates for about a month or so, and then reports to the relevant Minister in the Scottish Government his decision, which the Minister usually accepts. There is a further right of Appeal to the Court of Session, which is decided by Scottish Judges under Court Rules.

Whether or not EBS would accept the time and expense required for such an appeal (and the distant prospect of an appeal to the new UK ‘Supreme Court’ - the jurisdiction of which is in question in Scotland) is an open question. As a Professor Emeritus, I am not longer privy to EBS’s higher-level counsels and anyway cannot prudently speculate. I do know that the legal costs and salaries of the taxpayed officials of Scottish Heritage are comparatively inexhaustible, while EBS, as an educational charity, is not.

Meanwhile, we must hope that Panmure’s roof stays in place.

Labels:

Tuesday, March 01, 2011

Panmure House Inquiry Opens 2 and 3 March 2011

When Edinburgh Business School (Heriot-Watt University), bought Panmure House in 2008, the expectation was that the survey and restoration work (costing up to £3 million) would begin fairly quickly.

That expectation underestimated the obstruction caused by Scotland’s planning regulations. Panmure House was built in 1697 and was the residence of Adam Smith from 1778 until he died in 1790.

It lay semi-derelict for many years and latterly was used as a council-run club for ‘rowdy youths’. Internally it was renovated several times, leaving hardly anything of the original internal walls, stairs and structure. Only the outside walls remain, though in a poor state, as is the roof, of the original 17th-century structure.

The main objections to the EBS plans comes from a statuary state body, Scottish Heritage, focussing mainly its opposition to a proposed glass atrium, which would allow other state regulations on wheel-chair access to be met.

Because the parties are deadlocked, the Scottish Government has ‘called in’ the EBS proposals and appointed a Reporter to adjudicate and make a recommendation one way or the other, or, perhaps propose a compromise agreeable to the parties.

Wednesday’s meeting is the presentation of the EBS proposals and Thursday's is Scottish Heritage’s presentation of their objections. After this, the Reporter retires for about a month to consider his verdict and send it to the Scottish Government.

I shall attend the public sessions, hopefully on both days. I shall also report anything likely to be of interest to readers of Lost Legacy.

EBS intends to renovate Panmure House as an international postgraduate research centre for studies related to Adam Smith, and others in the Scottish Enlightenment, and how markets can to social benefits (no- nothing about 'invisible hand' myths!).

Labels:

Sunday, January 16, 2011

IMPORTANT: Adam Smith's Panmure House Project in the Bureaucratic Balance

Bill Jamieson (16 January) writes in Scottish national daily newspaper, The Scotsman, HERE:

IMPORTANT INFORMATION:

“Adam Smith’s Old House Needs to be Made Accessible to All”

“LIKE so many dreams that turn to nightmares, it seemed a good idea at the time. Three years ago this spring, the Edinburgh Business School offshoot of Heriot-Watt University appeared to have pulled off a coup.


Bill Jamieson hopes plans for Panmure House, which was rebuilt in 1956, are approved soon 

It won a bid to buy the house, just off Edinburgh's Royal Mile, where Adam Smith spent his last years. Panmure House in the Canongate, close by the churchyard where the philosopher is buried, had fallen on bad times. Edinburgh City Council was glad to be shot of it – and the contingent costs of saving it from its dilapidated state. 

Panmure House and its heritage is one of Scotland's treasures, and its neglect a national scandal. This was not just a home to one of Scotland's greatest thinkers and philosophers. It was the epicentre of the Scottish Enlightenment. Smith's dinner guests at Panmure House on Sunday evenings included Adam Ferguson, widely regarded as a pioneer of sociology; William Robertson, Principal of Edinburgh University and Moderator of the Church of Scotland; Joseph Black, a chemist who discovered Latent Heat; Edmund Burke, philosopher and politician; John Hume, playwright and brother of Smith's famous friend, the moral philosopher and historian, David; John Adams, architect and designer of splendid Georgian buildings in Edinburgh, and John Playfair, Professor of Mathematics at Edinburgh.

Here was an opportunity for an ambitious restoration befitting the greatest contributor to the Scottish Enlightenment, one that would bring the building back to life as a research and meeting centre. 

Heriot-Watt, which paid £800,000, quickly saw that here was a building that could be used, not just displayed, that would be a centre for debate and discussion, not just a storage archive. And that absolutely suited the council's stipulation that the building be used for educational purposes. 

The intervention was widely hailed in Scotland. And news travelled fast round the academic world. The American Economics Association expressed keen interest. Before long, Heriot-Watt had attracted offers of help towards refurbishment totalling a potential £3 million. Here at last, not only would the author of The Wealth of Nations be properly honoured, but the university would also have a research centre and seminar facility in the heart of the capital that would attract visitors from across the world. 

Today, almost three years later, not a brick has been laid or even a path cleared. Panmure House remains padlocked and abandoned. The best-laid plans have come to nothing. And Heriot-Watt is now staring into a financial black hole. Panmure House is on the brink of turning into a doomed and disastrously expensive foray into heritage bureaucracy. The fate of the project – delayed by obstacles, clashes and delays – now hangs precariously on the outcome of a public inquiry on 3 March.


How has it come to this? It is an irony that Adam Smith himself would have appreciated, that a gesture to rescue and revive a building abandoned and forgotten for years has suddenly attracted health and safety, heritage and aesthetic interventions bringing delay and despair. Heriot-Watt, says Sir Alan Peacock, economics guru and co-author with Gavin Kennedy, Emeritus Professor at the Edinburgh Business School of a paper on the cultural importance of Panmure House, "has been put through all the hoops".

Barely had the university begun considering outline plans for refurbishment and renewal than building inspectors insisted on appropriate facilities for disabled access. Heriot-Watt's architects EK:JN duly obliged. By March 2009 they presented plans for a new octagonal stair tower and a turret, offering disabled access, modelled on Ford House in Midlothian.

Enter Historic Scotland. It made a site visit and immediately wrote to the city council expressing "strong concerns" over the plans. EK:JN then submitted further proposals in July of that year for the extension of the building. This featured a glass atrium extension to enable it to be used as a meeting place with lecture facilities, in compliance with the council's stipulation. This, as Keith Lumsden, director of the Edinburgh Business School at Heriot-Watt explained, fulfilled both functional requirements and opening up the original stonework to view.
Historic Scotland again objected. Steven Robb, senior inspector of historic buildings, wrote that the atrium and stair would affect the character and special interest of the building "to an unacceptable degree". The plan, he said, would alter the entrance elevation, adding that an external stair was not essential to its reuse. These concerns were repeated in a further letter by Historic Scotland to the council in August of that year. But these objections, Lumsden argued, would make it impossible to develop the house as a seminar centre and meeting place with all the facilities that would be required.

Six months later, in March 2010, Heriot-Watt's plans were formally considered by the city council. Its planning department had recommended refusal. But the planning committee overturned this after a site visit, voting decisively 11 to one in favour.

Barely had the applicants time to celebrate this progress than on 13 August Scottish ministers called in the proposals for examination. Heriot-Watt, sensing that this would prove not the beginning of the end but the end of the beginning, demanded a public inquiry. It believes it has a cast-iron case and a compelling proposal that would bring the crumbling Panmure House back to life, providing an academic magnet at the heart of the city.

What lies at the heart of Historic Scotland's objections? Is it being over fussy, or are there valid concerns? Panmure House was built between 1691 and 1693 by Lt Col George Murray, who sold it in 1696 to James Maule, 4th Earl of Panmure. It passed to the Earl of Dalhousie, a relation. Adam Smith rented the building from 1778 until his death in 1790. It was a two-storey building with basement and attic. A rental agreement of 1753 describes it as having a large dining room and drawing room (ground floor), three good bedchambers with closets and conveniences on the same floor and a basement kitchen below.

As a building it has since been through the wars and there is little now that has survived the time of Smith's occupancy. In the 1840s the northern wing was removed. When the area became industrialised, the grounds were occupied by the Panmure Iron Foundry. By the 1950s the building, according to a Historic Scotland summary, "was ruinous, vandalised and only stone stubs of the internal stair remained." In the mid 1950s the architect John Wilson Paterson converted it for use as a home for delinquent boys, the floors at ground and first floor having already disappeared.

In 1970 the building was Category A listed.

Historic Scotland's concerns are not without merit. This is a rare example of a 17th-century town house within the historic Old Town. The original stone structure presents a sturdy frame. But virtually everything that was within at the time of Smith's occupancy has long gone. It was abandoned, then made over in the 1950s, then abandoned again. What's left is less artefact than association. The case for preservation cannot rest on architectural merit: the building has been internally gutted. So how much of this objection is on heritage grounds – and how much on aesthetics?

The surrounding built environment is very mixed and cannot be said to hold to a particular style or vernacular. The building is shielded from the Canongate by a circa-1930 tenement block providing undistinguished, if not grim, "infill" development. There are also some tenements by Sir Basil Spence, an acquired enthusiasm for many. As Panmure House is not visible from the Canongate, its appearance does not bear on the thrilling Hanseatic style of the Royal Mile as one looks up towards St Giles. As for looking down to Holyrood, there is of course the Scottish Parliament: a building that will forever struggle to avoid that most searing thunderball of condemnation in the entire Edinburgh lexicon of put-down: "inappropriate".

There is the gem of a charming little garden nearby in Dunbar Close, laid out in the formal 17th-century style by Seamus Filor in 1976, but barely known or visited. A refurbished Panmure House would bring fresh interest.

Historic Scotland does have an important role to ensure that as much as possible of the original building is preserved. But specifying what should constitute "re-use" is surely not in its bailiwick. And the dismissal of the disabled-access turret smacks of subjective judgement.

The key point here surely is that this is a historic building transferred on the understanding that it would be used for educational purposes. It has to cater for events and meetings and not just be an archival museum. Heriot-Watt paid £800,000 in good faith and has mustered funds to meet that obligation. What it has submitted is no golden arches McDonald's restaurant or a sprawling and distraught Catalan indulgence, but a refurbishment and extension that serves functionality while opening up the building to wonder and inspection. It has stepped up to provide an immense enrichment to the legacy of Adam Smith where a neglected structure now stands. And it would be an inspiring addition to the city's cultural meeting points that would draw international attention. But the fate of the entire project now dangles at the end of a planning inquiry. The Wealth of Nations offers no guidance on the conduct and function of such inquiries. But I suspect the author would have looked on this three-year episode at the heart of Scotland's capital city – and wept.”


[Letters and Messages of support please to: news.scotsman.com
or Barclay House, 108 Holyrood Road, Edinburgh, EH8 8AS, Scotland, UK (Telephone: + 44 131 6208620)]

Labels:

Friday, March 26, 2010

First Hurdle Cleared

The Edinburgh City Council planning committee has approved by an unopposed vote the plans of Edinburgh Business School, Heriot-Watt University for the renovation of Panmure House (1690), Adam Smith's home in Edinburgh from 1788 until he died in 1790.

This is a welcome move, though one of many necessary before work can begin, on the actual renovation, which may cost up to several millions of pounds to complete. The architect's plans, include the construction of a glass atrium across the front of the 'L'-shaped building, and it looks great too. This will provide access to both floors, including for those disabled, in keeping with sensible public policy.

As each step occurs, I shall keep Lost Legacy informed of progress.

Labels:

Thursday, January 14, 2010

Adam Smith's Panmure House - Centre of the Scottish Enlightenment

Brian Monteith writes in The Scotsman HERE

“See beyond glass to get Smith's house in order.”

“Small buildings like Panmure House, just off the Royal Mile, and the former home of Adam Smith, the founder of modern economics. For the last 50 years, it has, unfortunately, been owned by various public bodies that showed no concern for its history or its preservation.

Its interior was once rich with original features. Now all that remains, other than a sturdy stone hulk with dull and dilapidated magnolia rooms, is one original fireplace – in the attic! Everything else was stripped out as it was used to deliver utilitarian democratic socialism or some other value-free ideal.

Fortunately, Panmure House has new owners. The Edinburgh Business School – a commercial wing of Heriot-Watt University that appropriately teaches market economics – bought it last year with the specific promise that it would return the building to the role of a meeting place to discuss the social, economic and philosophical issues of the day, as Adam Smith used it for.

Smith would regularly have the great minds of Scotland's Enlightenment round for Sunday lunch and a blether, and what better than to return the house to such a use? Not least as it is only a short hop from a parliament badly in need of some clear and original thinking.

However, like so many other charming buildings of its size, turning it into a public building that meets all the regulations of today requires a lift, fire escapes and other physical intrusions that make renovation expensive and difficult to comply with planning regulations.

It would be a pity, and ironic, if Smith's house could not be used for the sort of discussions he used to hold in it, just because of modern-day bureaucracy.

To resolve the difficulties – mainly caused by a lack of space – the architects have come up with a glass atrium that sits outside the façade of the building, providing a meeting space and stairs. Although some might consider this nothing more than a glass box, it is in fact an intelligent way out of the conundrum……

Needless to say Historic Scotland – commonly known as Hysterical Scotland amongst many professionals – is objecting to anything that does not use old materials or is not a faux bolt-on. The only alternative is to turn the house into a private home, but a private domestic owner would not be obliged to provide public access, certainly not every day”
.

Comment
Bought two years ago it has taken this long to get into the decision process with the city planners abotu the renovation of Adam Smith's Panmure House.

No public money is involved. Edinburgh Business School is self-funded from the educational provision it provides. (I am just finishing ome last minute post-graduate exam papers - it'd my old day-job before retirement in 2005).

Follow the link for more news.

Labels:

Monday, January 04, 2010

Adam Smith as Theologian?

James Otteson, joint professor of philosophy and economics at Yeshiva University in New York, posts on his blog HERE news of a new book from Routledge, under the title: Adam Smith as Theologian, which is edited by Paul Oslington, professor in economics and theology at the Australian Catholic University, Sydney

Worth a Look: "Adam Smith as Theologian"

"Routledge is bringing out a fascinating collection of articles (disclosure: one of them is mine) on the theological underpinnings of Adam Smith's work. Entitled Adam Smith as Theologian, it is edited by Paul Oslington, who is joint chair in economics and theology at Australian Catholic University. The essays were written for an enormously stimulating conference sponsored by the Templeton Foundation that was held in January of 2009 at the University of Edinburgh, Scotland.

James Otteson writes; “One might be surprised to hear that Smith even had a theology, let alone that a series of penetrating essays could be written on the subject. (Perhaps only a conference on "David Hume as Theologian" could be more surprising!
)” I concur with James’ last statement teasing about David Hume.

Last January I was invited to attend a session of the conference – dinner actually, and very nice it was too – and gave a 15-minute talk on "Adam Smith in Edinburgh" to the conference diners in the side-room of a lovely restaurant.

Earlier that day I had accompanied Paul Oslington – a young academic of impeccable manners – in a short tour of Edinburgh’s High Street/Royal mile between the castle and the Holyrood palace. We started at the new Adam Smith statue, just beyond the Mercat Cross and opposite what is now Edinburgh City Chambers (a splendid local government building, where Adam Smith worked from 1778-90 as a Scottish Commissioner of Customs and the Salt Duty) and walked down towards the palace, past John Knox’s house (a formidable firebrand protestant preacher), to Smith’s grave in the Canongate Churchyard), looking a lot better since it was tidied up from a donation from Canada.

Unfortunately, I did not have the keys then to Panmure House,* where Smith lived with his mother, his cousin Janet and his nephew and heir. We walked round it instead.

I look forward to reading the conference papers. Clearly, the contributors take a different stance on the subject of Smith’s Theology – the title is as provocative as you can get (in the nicest possible way, of course). Next month, 11 February, to be confirmed, I am to attend a seminar at the Australian Catholic University, Sydney, at the invitation of Paul Oslington, to which I look forward, where no doubt we shall discuss themes around Smith’s alleged theology.

For those interested, my paper, written before (but NOT for!) the Edinburgh Templeton Foundation conference, “The Hidden Adam Smith in his Alleged Theology” is available on request from me (gavin aT negweb. DoT com).

For those curious about Paul Oslington’s edited volume, here is the list of papers in it:

Smith in Context 1. The Influence of Religious Thinking on the Smithian Revolution Benjamin Friedman 2. Smith and Natural Law John Haldane 3. Smith and Augustine Eric Gregory 4. Christian Freedom in Political Economy: The Legacy of John Calvin in Adam Smith Joe Blosser 5.Providence and Adam Smith’s Invisible Hand Paul Oslington Part II: Analysis and Assessment of Adam Smith’s Theology 6. Economics as Theology: Adam Smith’s Wealth of Nations Anthony Waterman 7. Adam Smith, Natural Theology, and the Natural Sciences Peter Harrison 8. God and Smith’s Impartial Spectator James Otteson 9. Adam Smith’s Theodicy Brendan Long 10. A Divine Economy? Assessing Adam Smith’s Theology Adrian Pabst 11. Man and Society in Adam Smith’s Natural Morality: The Impartial Spectator, the Man of System, and the Invisible Hand Ross B. Emmett Part III: Contemporary Reflections 12. The Contemporary Relevance of Adam Smith Arjo Klamer 13. The Moral Basis of Capitalism: Reflections on Adam Smith’s Theory of Moral Sentiments Paul S. Williams.

It’s available in 2010 (the publishers say on 1 November: ISBN 978-0-415-88071-8)

[*] Panmure House is now owned by Edinburgh Business School (my former day job) and History of Economics Society members visiting Edinburgh who contact me may get access, assuming I am available, and reconstruction work permits.

Labels: ,