Saturday, November 05, 2011

More Details on Professor Meeropol’s Critique of the Modern Myths of the Invisible Hand: Worthy of Your Attention (Part One)

Part One

From ”Another Distortion of Adam Smith: The Case of the "Invisible Hand", Michael Meeropol 2004, Political Economy Institute (University of Massachusetts, Amhurst HERE.

I quote the key sentences of the three paragraphs and a long footnote because they encapsulate the first, real evidence-based analytical breaks with the modern myths about Adam Smith’s so-called ”invisible hand’ that I have seen since Lost Legacy began in 2005. I think they should be taken seriously by all readers, despite my own humble reservations that they have not quite understood what Adam Smith was actually and modestly saying in his two references to the IH metaphor in the two works (published in his lifetime), Moral Sentiments and Wealth Of Nations, compared to what has been claimed for him since Paul Samuelson’s textbook, Economics: an analytical introduction, McGraw Hill, 1948 and its subsequent editions had such an impact on modern economics education. (Also, we may note that Professor Meeropol acknowledges Noam Chomsky’s influence in his studies.)

I agree with the first two paragraphs as representative of the modern myth of the IH metaphor.

“… Smith referred to the invisible hand once in his earlier work The Theory of Moral Sentiments. Here he argued that despite the desire to accumulate vast riches, individuals who were in a position to do so were forced to … divide with the poor the produce of all their improvements. They [owners] are led by an invisible hand to make nearly the same distribution of the necessaries of life which would have been made had the earth been divided into equal portions among all its inhabitants; and thus, without intending it, … advance the interest of the society, and afford means to the multiplication of the species.”

“Adam Smith on the other hand, as the above quote makes clear, believed that a relatively equal distribution of “the necessaries of life” would be in the best interest of society as a whole. “It is clear that Adam Smith, at least the Smith of The Theory of Moral Sentiments, believed that the invisible hand was already at work guaranteeing the necessities of life for the poor. How quaint Smith’s idea appears today
.”

Comment
Yes, but. By the “necessaries of life” Smith was not talking anything about an equality of distribution among the very rich feudal landlords and the working poor peasantry (slaves, serfs, and such like, at the bottom of the heap). The gross inequalities of this period in human history were manifest: serfs and their families lived in wooden hovels; the landlords families and armed retainers lived in their impregnable castles, sat by roaring fires, dressed warmly, and drank their fill, ate off platters of food, served by servile women.

And by “necessaries” Smith referred to a share (i.e., the amounts decided by the landlords’ overseers, not a benevolent ruler subject to the legal restraints) of the “necessaries” only, but not the “conveniences, and amusements of life” (Smith’s definition of wealth). In short, bare subsistence was the life-long norm. 21st-century US university professors and Harvard students may have too rosy a (Hollywood) picture of life in the agrarian kingdoms of the millennia before capitalism, after some, later more, humans left the forests and the plains for good in Europe, parts of Asia, from 11,000 years ago. Life in the forests from hunting provided subsistence in “necessaries” (the much favoured optima among some today), and the Ages of shepherding and Agriculture were not much improved upon for the labouring majority fed by their over-lords, and at their mercy, who had no real alternative but to distribute strictly-limited “necessaries” to them to keep them alive in order to benefit from their work and in the lords' wars. But of “conveniences” (warm clothes, utensils, etc.,) there was little extravagance. Of “amusements” (what passed for luxuries) little if any were shared with them. Their lives too were precarious. Freedom was unknown. Even the barons were ruled capriciously by Kings, until Magna Carta curbed their excesses, slightly and as a bye-product.

The absolute necessity of some minimal subsistence was available (no food, no labour; no labour, no food) which led their overlords to keep them alive; this was the “invisible hand” metaphor to which Smith referred; a perfect metaphor for their rulers being led to do what was necessary for them to do if there was to be a continuation of the species (it had nothing to with Providence). In the slowly rising gross output of these societies, basic subsistence was maintained for a rising population (in good years), but the diversion of rising output and labour to castles, churches, temples, and armies, accounted for the rest, including what passed for “amusements” among the rich lords and kings (sparking off nascent inter-regional trade). Basic GDP per capita, showed by Deidre McCLoskey’s, Bourgeois Dignity, remained below the equivalent of a nominal $3 a day for many millennia. That is the reality that commercial society slowly (too slowly) began to replace eventually for poor labourers from the 14th century onwards, accelerating from the 1800s to today’s unprecedented levels, which some philosophers consider to be too a negativeoutcome. (They can always try living on $3 a day in pursuit of ‘happinness’.)

“Smith would also have recoiled in horror from the gross inequalities that the world has experienced in the previous two centuries, as some nations have grown extremely wealthy. Based on his belief in the importance of some semblance of equality at least in the distribution of the “necessaries of life,” he would have looked at the world today and condemned it asserting, “This is not what I expected from the invisible hand.”

An imaginative piece of propaganda that is uncalled for in an academic paper. I suggest an immersion by these scholars in the realities of life for poor the majority in 18th-century Scotland, and for all indigenous people in Africa and the Americas, while Smith was alive. Smith “recoiled in horror” from the treatment of the indigenous peoples (the Atlantic slave trade, and in the Spanish colonies), and would have welcomed the abolition of the Atlantic slave trade, the prospects for which he was pessimistic about, without knowing about the far larger African slave trades of the Arab rulers that continued well into the 19th century.

Turning to footnote 14, we move to the substance of Michael Meeropol’s analysis of the myths of the invisible hand, which are mostly right, but still slightly off beam.

“The author consulted 10 Principles textbooks and every one of them mentioned the invisible hand as illustrating the role of competition in guiding private interests to serve public ends without revealing what Smith actually said. Some utilize the well-known quote by Smith; “It is not from the benevolence of the butcher, the brewer or the baker that we expect our dinner, but from their regard for their own interest.”(I: 18) This quote is specifically identified as illustrating the invisible hand principle even though Smith’s reference to the invisible hand is hundreds of pages later in a different context.”

Comment
“It is not from the benevolence of the butcher, the brewer or the baker that we expect our dinner, but from their regard for their own interest.” (I: 18)

Michael Meeropol is correct. This quote had nothing to do with the invisible hand metaphor. It is about the basic Smithian point that in order to realize one’s own self-interest in acquiring the contents of one’s dinner, it is necessary to appeal to the “self-love’ of the other person and not to one’s own ‘necessities’. In short, to be successful in a self-regarding transaction, he advised readers to be “other regarding” in respect of the self-interests of the “butcher, brewer, baker”, and not to rely upon their benevolence. Self-regarding is not selfishness; self-interest only works if each individual demonstrates a regard for other people in their transaction with them – it is after all, a paragraph in a section explaining how bargaining works in society (WN I.ii.2: 2-27). (Continued below)

Labels:

Friday, September 23, 2011

Robert Frank's Book: a Review (continued)

A Review of Robert H. Frank, ‘The Darwin Economy: liberty, competition, and the common good’, Princeton, New Jersey, Princeton University Press. September 2011.

PART TWO

This brings me to a fundamental problem with Frank’s perspective (though I have no political axe to grind). His entire thesis about Adam Smith is based on a set of myths created in the 20th century by modern economists, one ubiquitous example spread notably by Paul Samuelson (Kennedy. G. 2010. ‘Paul Samuelson and the Invention of the Modern Economics of the Invisible Hand’. History of Economic Ideas, xviii/2010/3)

I refer to the modern myths of the use of Adam Smith’s ‘invisible hand’. Frank refers to this myth 32 times on my count, though they may be more. Smith used the IH metaphor twice only in his books published in this lifetime (Moral Sentiments and Wealth Of Nations). The metaphor was quite popular in the 17th-18th centuries (Peter Harrison of Oxford lists over 40 occasions; History of Ideas, 2010) before Smith used it. I have discussed it on Lost Legacy almost every week since 2005. I shall not rehearse Smith’s meaning here (scroll down this year’s posts for my analysis of the IH metaphor; see also Kennedy, G. 2011. “Adam Smith and the Role of the Invisible Hand”, Economic Affairs, Vol. 31, Issue 1, 43-52).

To state it bluntly, Frank and most modern economists purvey a myth of the IH metaphor. Smith’s use was hardly commented on while he lived and during much of the 19th century, and numbered only about a half-dozen mentions from 1875-1900). Even in the early decades of the 20th century, it remained within an oral tradition at Cambridge (UK) and Chicago (US), with less than an handful of published comments (eg., Pigou, Gray, and Lange).

It began its modern journey to ubiquity after Samuelson’s text, Economics, in 1948, and through its 20 editions to 2010 – but Samuelson got it wrong (for details see my two references above). Frank calls it ‘a genuinely revolutionary insight’ (p 17) and ‘an extraordinary narrative’ (p 18). He continues that ‘behind the invisible hand is greed’. Yet Smith never said such a thing. In fact, this suggests that Frank in not familiar with Smith’s views on ‘greed’ (see Moral Sentiments on Bernard Mandeville’s ‘licentious’ philosophy), nor, incidentally with Smith’s qualification of self-interest by the need for bargainers to be ‘other regarding’ and not just self-regarding, as shown, for example, in the very quotation by Frank of Smith’s ‘most widely quoted passage in Wealth Of Nations’ (p 33), which he quotes, but misreads completely (see WM, I.ii.2: p 26-7).

This brings me to recall the ‘prediction’ Frank makes “that economists a hundred years from now will be more likely to name Charles Darwin than Adam Smith as the intellectual founder of their discipline” (xii). I have no particular view on futile modern arguments about Adam Smith’s status as the ‘intellectual founder’ or ‘father of economics’, and such like, nor any axe to grind about other supposed ‘fathers’ or 'grand fathers'. But I am familiar with the work of Charles Darwin and I find Frank’s treatment disappointing.

Natural selection works through the individual, not the group. So when Frank writes: ‘A mutation that codes for keener eyesight in one particular hawk … serves the interests of every individual, but its inevitable spread also makes hawks as a species more successful’ (p 7), showing signs of sloppiness about Darwin on natural selection. Similarly, with his account of the growth of larger antlers (p 21), which make bull elks with the larger antlers likely to win fights for females to the disadvantage of rivals with less powerful antlers. Yes, but the process by which the genes for larger antlers are transferred to others is via a blind and unintentional inter-generational transfer to the descendants of the powerful bulls who mate with more females and sire more descendants, than the bulls with smaller antlers, which is a definite disadvantage to existing bulls with the smaller antlers and their fewer descendants. Likewise with the hawks. The hawk with the sharper eyesight catches more food than those without that advantage, and its descendants spread, to the certain disadvantage (even the expense of) of the descendants of those with less sharp eyesight, which were out-competed for food. The females of this disadvantaged group have fewer surviving off-spring and over time, these differences in eyesight have a noticeable affect eventually on the relative proportions of eyesight quality (minute differences over long periods of time can cause significant quantitative changes). Similarly, for the bull elks. But there is nothing that the Hawks or Bulls can do about it. Truly, in evolution you must play only the cards with which you are dealt, unintentionally by your parents.

For Frank to conclude by asserting that ‘Darwin’s natural selection narrative closely tracks Smith’s invisible hand narrative’ is pure hyperbole in his idea of ‘closely tracks’ (p 20); they are not even related via the IH metaphor, as used by Smith. In fact, the IH metaphor’ was not even a ‘narrative’, it was, well, a metaphor – to understand the difference (see Adam Smith: Lectures on Rhetoric and Belles Lettres’, [1763] 1983, p 29, or the Oxford English Dictionary under metaphor).

Humans are able to make choices about courses of action, though not about natural selection; hawks, bull elks, and throughout all species, are not endowed with choices about their natural characteristics. They are subject to blind natural selection in Darwin’s account. No elk can endow itself with larger antlers, nor can any hawk create for itself sharper eyesight. Neither can humans but humans can adopt conscious behaviours or social arrangements that aim to be advantageous individually, though not necessarily advantageous for the group. Elks cannot stop arms races, though nature might, but humans can stop arms races. That is more than a Darwinian difference.

The entire history for the human species since it emerged from the hominine line is a testament to the outcomes of the choices that some humans made in contrast to that which other humans did not make – a few descendants left Africa for Asia and Europe, a few then went south towards Australia, later a few crossed the land bridge between Siberia and North America, some of those eventually left Alaska for the great plains east, others followed the mountains south. Whether any humans ever got (or have ever gotten, or ever will get) their social arrangements ‘right’ is pure opinion (and possibly a triumph of hope over experience). And we know Frank’s opinion of the current arrangements, because his book is an articulate testament to his dissatisfaction.

Neither the political economy enunciated by the Adam Smith born in 1723 in Kirkcaldy and/or the Charles Darwin of the 19th century can decide whether Frank’s hoped for changes to the world’s social arrangements will ever be realised. I am also sure that the cardboard constructs of the Adam Smith, supposedly ‘alive and well in Chicago’ (George Stigler), will have little to do with whatever happens in a 100 years time when future generations judge the relative merits of these two remarkable scientists. Remember, Adam Smith was not given to predict the future (with one exception, when he predicted that the former British colonies in North America would become richer than Europe by the 1880s).

We should read what Smith actually wrote in his Moral Sentiments and Wealth Of Nations and what Darwin wrote in his Origin of Species and his associated 4 volumes. We should not rely on the claims of modern epigones.

Franks book needs a careful treatment by readers.

Labels: ,