Wednesday, December 21, 2011

Chris Dillow is Right: History Does MATTER!

Chris Dillow writes (20 December) the intelligent Blog, Stumbing and Mumbling’ (it grows on you), self-billed as “An extremist, not a fanatic:
HERE

“HISTORY MATTERS”

“I am one of the richest humans who ever lived. This is not because I am uniquely hard-working or intelligent; such notions are only slightly less cretinous than the idea that I owe my wealth to my great social skills. Instead, I’m rich because I had the good fortune to have born in England in the late 20th century* - in a time and place where history has been kind.
We are not self-made men, but rather creatures of history.

And if history is so powerful an influence, other things are less so - one of these being the managerialist whims of politicians.
It’s in this context that we should regret the decline of history teaching.
Herein lies a paradox. I get the impression that those who would most like to see history given more importance in schools are Tory traditionalists who want to teach some Sellar and Yeatman-style story of our sceptre’d isle. However, Sellar and Yeatman were wrong**. History is not just “what you can remember.“ It has effects whether you know it or not. We are who we are because our ancestors did what they did. Knowing this, however, undermines right-wing fairy tales about people being the products of their own decisions. In this sense, Tories are the last people who should want history taught.
”

Comment
That’s very Smith-like too. He studied history to write about what brought Britain to the way it had become in the 18th-century. It is also why he did not make a habit of making predictions about what would happen, which seems to be the main feature of the modern economics profession. Indeed, economists are expected, and are hired at good salaries and pension plans, to predict the immediate future – they seldom make predictions about the far future (unless they are climate-change specialists).

I share Chris Dillow’s regrets about the decline of history in our education systems. I am also even more regretful about the recent decline among economics departments in academe of the rapid, and near extinction, of the teaching of the history of economic thought, as a taught subject in both undergraduate and graduate teaching and research, hastened by the deliberate downgrading of the status of the history of economic thought by the controllers of the professional journals – the main route to appointment, let alone recruitment, in academic department - and the habits of appointment committees.

This wanton ignorance of history shows in the shameless failure of academic economists to show average success, let alone fail to excel, in their short- to medium-term predictions of the economies they claim to have familiarity with. Predictions in theory ‘ought’ to be possible, but the real world is not like that, whatever the shyster palm-readers claim to do (do you get regular copies of their glossy promises too?).

Understanding how we get to where we are is more productive of positive results in showing what may/could be done to improve performances of whatever our momentary concerns.

Smith’s Wealth Of Nations is a deep criticism of mid-18th century political economy – his “violent attack” Smith called it on the “whole commercial system of Britain” - was dominated by economic thinking from the past and the prejudices of government ministers and sovereigns. He did not make predictions that if everything was changed to meet some ideal conditions, such as the abolition of tariffs, no government regulations, no “jealousy of trade”, immediate adoption of “laissez-faire” - he never mentioned the words – and, above all, leave markets to the so-called “invisible hand” - he never spoke of this metaphor in relation to markets, all would be right with the world.

Now, many economists of left and right believe, with the passions of ignorant certitude, that these were what Adam Smith was about. He wasn’t.

He studied history in all that he wrote from his first (unpublished in his lifetime) essay on the History Of Astronomy to the last editions of Moral Sentiments and Wealth Of Nations, and he drew conclusions from what he learned about how the past continued to work in the present. He was never a revolutionary in a hurry. His proposals when they were made were cautious, careful, and measured against the realities of how society worked. He never fell for the fallacies of the “wooden pieces on a chessboard”, nor did he advise governments, legislatures, or sovereigns to act as if people could be forced the act against their natures.

In short, I suggest economists study more history (and the history of our ideas are a good place to start), with, perhaps, a little less attention given to utopian mathematical, perfectly competitive models of non-existent economies, the create as they go along.

This task requires a detailed study of history, such as Smith made – and taught (see his Lectures On Jurisprudence, [1762-3] 1978) - and not from a skimpy passage through an invented ‘history’ of a few popular books.

Labels:

Monday, October 31, 2011

Another Excellent Review of Ian Simpson Ross's "Life of Adam Smith" (2nd Edition)

Maureen Harkin (Reed College). “Review of Ross, Ian Simpson, The Life of Adam Smith.” H-Albion, H-Net Reviews. October, 2011
HERE: http://www.h-net.org/reviews/showrev.php?id=31774

Ian Simpson Ross. The Life of Adam Smith. Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2010. ISBN 978-0-19-955003-6.
“Harkin on Ross's The Life of Adam Smith”

When Ian Simpson Ross published the first edition of his Life of Adam Smith in 1995 it had been many years since the last full-scale biography of his subject. Despite the status of The Wealth of Nations (1776) and to a lesser extent, The Theory of Moral Sentiments (1759), Smith had not, until quite recently, attracted much specifically biographical investigation. Before 1995 the most recent major biography had been W. R. Scott’s in 1937, preceded by John Rae’s in 1895 and the foundational text of all Smith biographies, Dugald Stewart’s short biographical sketch of 1795. For all the intimate knowledge Stewart had of Smith’s life and circle, his short narrative concluded with a note of disappointment, the suggestion being that the biographer’s task was, in the case of Smith, rendered extraordinarily difficult by the subject’s life being so “barren of incident.”

… Smith famously had most of his surviving incomplete manuscripts burnt by his executors in a deathbed bonfire a few days before his demise in July 1790; Stewart commented on Smith’s unusually strong dislike of students taking any notes at all on his lectures; and, as the editors of Smith’s correspondence in the Glasgow edition of his works noted in 1977, in the golden age of letter-writing, Smith produced a remarkably small body of correspondence. The total of surviving letters over a fifty-year period from 1740 to 1790 is well under two hundred, with only a few dozen more known to have existed. Such a record was reason both for friends like David Hume to complain of neglect to Smith, and for biographers to hesitate.

The co-editor of the 1977 volume of correspondence, part of the six-volume Glasgow edition of Smith’s works published between 1976 and 1987, was, of course, Ian Simpson Ross, and the meticulous reconstruction of the material circumstances of Smith’s life in the annotations to these letters formed the foundation for the extraordinary detail of his 1995 biography. Now within the same year, 2010, we have not only another major new biography of Adam Smith from Nicholas Phillipson, but a second edition of Ian Simpson Ross’s book. That Smith is now attracting this level of biographical investigation is not the product of the discovery of any major new letters, documents, or facts, but of the dramatic surge of interest in Smith and the reevaluation of the significance of his work across a range of disciplines over the last three or so decades--an interest that the Glasgow edition has itself helped to foster.

Simpson Ross’s biography was acclaimed on its first publication for its command of every material detail of Smith’s daily life in Glasgow and Edinburgh. In its twenty-four chapters it followed the major stages of his personal and professional life, his writing of The Wealth of Nations and the Theory, including his numerous revisions, and other projects. Part of the achievement of Simpson Ross’s book is precisely in its accretion of the details of daily life and the implicit challenge this posed to the traditional image of Smith as unsociable, traditional since Stewart’s first sketch of Smith as awkward in company. Simpson Ross’s portrait stressed instead the range and depth of Smith’s social and familial relationships. Smith’s actual responses to particular situations, however--bringing back the body after the death of the younger brother in his charge, the Duke of Buccleugh, to the family home, for example (p. 234)--remain necessarily somewhat conjectural in light of the absence of Smith’s direct commentary: “It seems ... ”; “It is likely …”; and so on.

The new edition updates the text in incorporating references, albeit necessarily rather brief ones, to the abundant important work on Smith since 1995 (Samuel Fleischacker, Ryan Patrick Hanley, Emma Rothschild et al.) in the text and notes. As in the 1995 edition, Simpson Ross’s focus is on establishing contexts and connections rather than on reinterpreting Smith’s texts. The overall structure of the book is little changed, though Simpson Ross provides a reorganized and expanded account of the social and intellectual context in which Smith turned, in late 1766, from his travels abroad to the composition of The Wealth of Nations. …

Two hundred and twenty years after his death, we now have two impressive and complementary recent biographies of Smith: Simpson Ross’s reconstruction of Smith’s society, daily life, writing habits, and relationships, and Phillipson’s tracking of the development of Smith’s ideas and intellectual character through his texts. While Simpson Ross’s study refrains from interweaving biography with a reinterpretation of Smith’s texts his work lays the strongest foundation for such interpretative work. His account will be mined for many years to come.

Labels:

Tuesday, September 13, 2011

Where Adam Smith Did Not Go to University

Jackie Kemp, in The Guardian, writes “Competition for places at Scottish universities will be fierce in 2012” (HERE):

“Adam Smith, Charles Darwin, a couple of signatories of the American Declaration of Independence and Gordon Brown all graduated from Scotland's premier university – Edinburgh. A degree from the ancient institution – recently ranked 20th in the QS world rankings, above Berkeley, California, and the London School of Economics – is the gold standard of Scottish education. But some fear that next year the creme de la creme of Scottish schools could miss out on places, turned away in favour of students prepared to pay English gold.”

Comment
Among the many fine attributes of Edinburgh University, having Adam Smith as a graduate - or even as a student - was not one of them.

Adam Smith did not graduate from Edinburgh University.

Adam Smith attended Glasgow University from 1737 to 1740. He won a Snell Exhibition to Balliol College, Oxford from 1740 to 1746. His LL.D was awarded by Glasgow University in 1763.

Adam Smith gave a series of pubic lectures on Rhetoric in Edinburgh town - not the university - from 1748-51, sponsored by Lord Kames and from his paying audience, including some divinity and law students, he earned £100 a year (according to David Hume, who did attend Edinburgh University in 1723).

Labels:

Tuesday, March 15, 2011

Adam Smith's Lecturing Technique By One of his Students

“There was no situation in which the abilities of Mr Smith appeared to greater advantage than as a Professor. In delivering his lectures, he trusted almost entirely to extemporary elocution. His manner, though not graceful, was plain and unaffected;
and, as he seemed to be always interested in the subject, he never failed to interest his hearers. Each discourse consisted commonly of several distinct propositions, which he successively endeavoured to prove and illustrate. These propositions, when announced in general terms, had, from their extent, not unfrequently something of the air of a paradox. In his attempts to explain them, he often appeared, at first, not to be sufficiently possessed of the subject, and spoke with some hesitation. As he advanced, however, the matter seemed to crowd upon him, his manner became warm and animated, and his expression easy and fluent. In points susceptible of controversy, you could easily discern, that he secretly conceived an opposition to his opinions, and that he was led upon this account to support them with greater energy and vehemence. By the fulness and variety of his illustrations, the subject gradually swelled in his hands, and acquired a dimension which, without a tedious repetition of the same views, was calculated to seize the attention of his audience, and to afford them pleasure, as well as instruction, in following the same object, through all the diversity of shades and aspects in which it was presented, and afterwards in tracing it backwards to that original proposition or general truth from which this beautiful train of speculation had proceeded’ (in Stewart, Account …, in EPS, 275-6).

Comment
John Millar, Professor of Law at the University of Glasgow, former pupil and long- time friend of Adam Smith, quoted by Dugald Stewart, in his Biographical “Account of the Life and Writings of Adam Smith, LL.D”, which formed his eulogy to Adam Smith before the Royal Society of Edinburgh, 1793, and published in first in the Royal Society’s Transactions, volume 3, 1794, and also appeared in every edition of Moral Sentiments throughout the 19th century. It was republished in Essays On Philosophical Subjects (1980) as volume III of the Glasgow edition of the Works and Correspondence of Adam Smith, pages 265-351.

I have posted this extract from the first biography of Adam Smith because it is related to the extract, quoted below of Adam Smith’s parable of an imagined Chinese earthquake that is reported in Moral Sentiments (1759).

It demonstrates Smith’s lecturing technique, used to effect to make his philosophical comments legible to his student listeners and his readers, which should be borne in mind when considering the importance of this (and many other) examples of this method in his books.

Carelessly stopping a quotation after the first few sentences of a paragraph can lead to misleading conclusions about Smith’s actual views that do not reflect the main points of his discourses. This is often seen clearly in the erroneous notions that often proliferate in modern media and even (shame on them) among modern scholars about Adam Smith's actual views.

Labels:

Friday, November 05, 2010

A Review of Ian Simpson Ross, The Life of Adam Smith, 2010 (2nd edition): Part 2: Early Years



IMPORTANT NOTICE

ADAM SMITH’S LOST LEGACY HAS BEEN MOVED BY “BLOGGER”, THE HOST SITE, TO A NEW ADDRESS:


TO FOLLOW ALL 2083 POSTS (AND COUNTNG) FROM HERE TO 2012 AND BEYOND, PLEASE USE THE NEW ADDRESS.

THANK YOU

Gavin Kennedy
The preface to the second edition contains this paragraph from Ian Ross:

“If Smith is one of the inventors of the modern world, what kind of nightmare did he bring upon us? Alternatively, if he did inquire successfully into the origin of wealth and how it is constituted, why is his message so badly misunderstood and misapplied? Well, the story of his life and books tells us he was very far from being an optimistic promoter of market fundamentalism. He accused himself of having a ‘melancholy and evil boding mind’, and denounced ‘prodigals and projectors’ who sought to enrich themselves at the expense of others, with schemes that mingled folly with knavery. He was suspicious of governments, and equally so of merchants and manufacturers scheming to deceive the public by cornering the market or engagement in other malpractices. He believed that fair and lawful competition in the market would lead to fairness in compensation or producers, as well as fair pricing for consumers, everywhere in the world, not just in domains favoured at the expense of others. It seems to me, also, he would esteem the idea emanating from Ludwig Erhard and others in the post-World War Two era, about nations endorsing the social market based on free and fair competition, going along with responsible provision for a safety net for health care, pensions, and unemployment insurance.

He was outraged by the practice of slavery, especially in Africa, and I think he would be very concerned about the continent’s suffering from sickness, hunger, internecine war, and environmental damage, and how best to overcome this. Perhaps he would recognize in the current debate over international support – represented for example, by Dr Dambisa Moyo’s challenging book, Dead Aid (2009) – some elements of his own thinking, namely, that charity is not the answer to social, economic, and political malfunction, and that large capital inflows to distressed countries seem to correlate with diminished government accountability. Dr Mayo counsels that development funds should be raised on the financial markets through bond issues, with governments accountable to investors and to their citizens, who would pay taxes to clear the interest charges on the bonds. This may be an oversimplification of a very complex situation, however, and Smith would have been interested in alternative ways suggested for promoting development: assistance through ‘peacekeeping, security guarantees, trade privileges, and governance’ (Paul Collier. ‘Review of Dead Aid’, the Independent, 30 January, 2009)”. [Ross, I. S. Preface to the Second Edition, pp xix- xx].”


I open this review with these considered views of Ian Ross from his preface to the second edition, based on his long academic career as a scholar in 18th-century history. For some readers these ideas will be anathema to their own beliefs about what Adam Smith was about in publishing his two books, Moral Sentiments and Wealth Of Nations.

Given that most economists who regularly quote from Wealth Of Nations do not appear to have read it, because they rely on what they heard in their undergraduate classes some decades ago and supplement their vague memories of their tutors’ certainties with well-used quotations from journal articles written by others who also have not read him either, let alone a vast media presence that churns out the same quotations, torn from their original context, or just plain invented by so-called authorities, it is not surprising that ideological myths and other ‘harmless’ nonsense are so prevalent today.

Attend any academic conference, across several disciplines, besides economics, where Adam Smith is cited, or tossed into the discussion, or, indeed, where his Work is the main subject of the gathering, and be prepared to hear or read much that is at variance with what you will find in Ian Ross’s “The Life of Adam Smith”. There is a kaleidoscopic array of ‘Adam Smiths’, who never graced the streets of Kirkcaldy from 1723 to 1737, Glasgow from 1737-1740, Oxford from 1740 to 1746, Kirkcaldy and Edinburgh from 1746 – 1751, Glasgow from 1751-1764, France and Switzerland during 1766, London from 1766-67, Kirkcaldy from 1767-73, London from 1773-76, Kirkcaldy from 1776-78, Edinburgh from 1778-90 (Panmure House) (Smith, Correspondence, 1977, 1987). Among the many notorious examples of other ‘Adam Smiths’ we have the ‘Smith’ who was around MIT (Paul Samuelson, 1948) and later was ‘alive and well’ in Chicago (George Stigler, 1976).

Ian Ross, The Life of Adam Smith, is the timeless antidote to the multifarious ‘Adam Smiths’ invented (this not too strong a word for it) by some senior and otherwise distinguished modern economists in North America in the last half of the 20th century.

Ross opens with an account of the background to Smith’s family in Aberdeenshire and Kirkcaldy. This takes us into the major issue in Scotland at the turn of the 17th-18th centuries – the conflicts over dynastic-succession, with the side-issue of religious strife between Catholics and Protestants, between the ‘Jacobites’ supporting the Stuart kings versus the Hanoverian line of kings that replaced them (William and the Georges I to III), which rumbled on in Scotland to the bloody defeat of the mainly Highland armies at Culloden in April 1746 (and its disgusting, violent and merciless aftermath).

The religious causes of strife were the ever-present background to the controversial Union of the parliaments of Scotland and England in 1707, and its dire consequences in Scottish civil society while Smith grew from sickly child to university student and professor, in the home of his beloved and widowed mother, Margaret Douglas Smith. His father, also called Adam Smith died in January 1723 (he wrote his will in November 1722 and probably knew he was dying, perhaps also that his wife was pregnant). Baby Adam was born on or about 6 June (when the records show he was baptised).

Ian Ross, quite rightly, uses the dates as they ware recorded on all documents under the old calendar, which I find re-assuring because it rejects implicitly an unwelcome fashion that has appeared recently in some quarters to 'modernise' all dates before the great calendar change of 1751 by 11 days, which is a source of avoidable confusion. The dates in the extant documents should be left as those given by those wrote them. It is better in my view to jump ahead in 1751 by 11 days, supported by a single footnote, rather than pretend to rewrite all the thousands of dates on the hundreds of thousands of original documents, with confusing 11-day variances in everything recorded before 1751.

Ross trawls widely around Adam Smith’s early years at school and university to give an authoritative account of the milieu in which young Adam grew up and the early influences on him and his thinking. Several of his early influences in personnel continued to have strong relationships with him as kin, or mentors, and as fellow members of what is now known as the Scottish Enlightenment. He grew up and was educated in what was a scholarly fraternity upon which the Enlightenment took root across Scottish, English and French society from the 1750s. Reading Smith’s famous books without knowledge of this context is a rather barren feast, but Ross provides a bounteous remedy .

The growing ‘improvement’ in local farming – Smith’s relatives on his mother’s side were noted landowners – and a small but active commercial presence, supported by the small harbour in Kirkcaldy, provided evidence of the nascent changes taking place in the local, and, by extension, in the Scottish economy. Interestingly, Smith visited a near-by ‘naillery’, which may be the one to feature in his discussion of the division of labour in Wealth Of Nations and earlier in his Lectures On Jurisprudence.

Two other influences on young Adam were school and religion. School was the ‘sturdy, two-room building of the burgh school’ built in 1723, the year he was born. His teacher was David Miller, from whom he learned to read Latin and the rudiments of Greek, and elements of good English. These subjects had a distinctive and lasting influence on Smith. Ross reports on his mother’s religious influence (she was by all accounts a very religious person), and saw to his introduction to Calvinist theology of the Moderate Presbyterian strain.

Both school and home provided him with traits that were to last a lifetime. He ‘was well prepared intellectually for his student years and [for] finding a vocation as a moral philosopher and man of letters during the stimulating ere of his country’s history, marked by a determined drive for improved performance in agriculture and other economic sectors. Most important of all, his form of Presbyterian inheritance, together with the rudiments of training in the Latin classics, apparently instilled in him the values of a frugal lifestyle, self discipline of a stoic cast, diligence in his calling, and strict justice towards others tempered with benevolence which characterised his actions and his teaching. At the same times, it should be acknowledged that there were elements in the religious culture Smith encountered that could be oppressive in Kirkcaldy and restrictive…’ (p 37).

How these influences panned out is clearly identified by Ross in what follows.

Labels: ,

Wednesday, November 03, 2010

A Review of Ian Simpson Ross, The Life of Adam Smith, 2010 (2nd edition): Part 1: Introduction

A review: Ian Simpson Ross, “The Life of Adam Smith”, Oxford University Press (2010).

Part 1: Introduction


Ian Ross, “The Life of Adam Smith”, without doubt is recognised as the definitive account of the life and times of Adam Smith. The new second edition, published in September 2010, will ensure that Ross’s account in unlikely to be surpassed for decades to come.

The first biography, "An Account of the Life and Writings of Adam Smith, LL.D" was published in 1795 by a contemporary who knew him well, Dugald Stewart, Professor of Mathematics and then Professor of Moral Philosophy at the University of Edinburgh, who also knew many of Smith’s contemporaries too (Dugald’s father, Michael Stewart, was a fellow student with Smith at the University of Glasgow and Professor of Mathematics at Edinburgh). It remained the most commonly known account of Smith’s life until the end of the 19th century when John Rae published his “Life of Adam Smith” in 1895. William Robert Scott, carefully using the archives on Smith held at Glasgow University, published “Adam Smith as Student and Professor” in 1937. The aforementioned three authors and their books constitute the serious sources for Smith’s biographical works before 1995, when Ian Ross published “The Life of Adam Smith”.

Should new materials emerge, such as missing letters, and lecture notes, presently lying neglected in dusty and forgotten archives, all students of Adam Smith’s legacy would warmly welcome them. It is my hope that if and when the lofty powers that decide such things, give the go-ahead to Edinburgh Business School (Heriot-Watt University) for the renovation of Panmure House, Smith’s Edinburgh home from 1778 to 1790 (presently awaiting planning permission from the Scottish Government), the very existence of such a dedicated research centre will become widely known as the obvious place for the safe-keeping of any newly discovered letters to or from Adam Smith and other relevant materials that may be found.

Lecture notes by Smith’s students were discovered in 1896 in Oxford and Aberdeen in 1953 and various letters have turned up too. While the likelihood of there being many more unknown items to be discovered diminishes each year (Smith ordered from his death bed his private and unpublished papers to be burned), but something new and exciting may yet turn up. In the past three years, I know of two donors who offered their copies of Smith’s first editions of Wealth of Nations and Moral Sentiments to a relatively obscure charitable library in Scotland and to a private Edinburgh bank. If Panmure House had been well on the way to its needed and sympathetic renovation, instead of languishing in a planners’ limbo, and thereby available, I am sure a case could have been made for Smith’s former home acting as their trustee for their safe keeping and widespread, but secure, scholarly access. Panmure House is quite independent of public funding or private commercial interests.

Working with whatever scarce materials that we have is a major undertaking. That so much is written about what Adam Smith meant, and means today, by writers who, frankly, are ill-equipped in a basic knowledge of his life and Works, let alone his biographical details, is practically inexcusable, given the four serious biographies published since 1795 (now added to by a fifth excellent work, that of Nicholas Phillipson’s, “Adam Smith, an Enlightened Life”, published last month (and reviewed last week on Lost Legacy). That is why Ian Simpson Ross’s “The Life of Adam Smith” is of such importance: it set, and continues to set, the standard by which all other biographies of Adam Smith must be judged. Ross is the arbiter of scholarly authority on the details and themes of Adam Smith’s life and Works.

For this reason, Lost Legacy will provide my reader’s review of Ian Ross’s scholarship over the next few weeks (at least within my modest abilities). I shall raise questions, not normally raised, which have occurred to me since reading the first edition, and try to answer them as honestly as I can. I shall point out the lessons that appear to me to be fundamental to Smithian scholarship that point to the excellence of what Ian Ross has done, and why all serious scholars – and perhaps a few epigones too – should read carefully his “Life of Adam Smith”.

Labels:

Thursday, October 21, 2010

Again Another Review of Nicholas Phillipson's Biography of Adam Smith

Adam Gopnik, Books, “Market Man,” The New Yorker, 18 October, p. 82 (HERE)

Adam Gopnik, Books, “Market Man,” The New Yorker, October 18, 2010, p. 82

BOOKS review of Nicholas Phillipson’s “Adam Smith: An Enlightened Life” (Yale; $32.50).

"1776 was a good year for big ideas, a rare thing. It was also a big year for good ideas, an even rarer one. Our own big-deal Declaration was, in its way, the small pugnacious summary of Enlightenment ideas that had reached their apex that winter, in London.

In February, Edward Gibbon published the first volume of “The Decline and Fall of the Roman Empire.” Then, a month later, his friend Adam Smith published his big book, “The Wealth of Nations.” Classics of English prose, Gibbon’s and Smith’s books don’t just belong to the history of ideas; they helped establish the ideas of history and economics. But where Gibbon is a clear figure in shadowy light, a figure of the Enlightenment who found his place in the twilight of history where reason fell, Adam Smith is a shadowy figure in clear light. He is to most of us the invisible-hand guy, the Scottish face on the British twenty-pound note—the one who showed that greed was good, that the market, left to its own devices, would always set the right price and favor the right goods. Yet a very different Smith is current in the academy.

This Adam Smith is seen not as the apostle of the free market but as one of the fathers of the French Revolution, albeit the nicer, warmer bits of the French Revolution. None other than Noam Chomsky is a fan of this Smith, while one of the most original and mind-altering academic works of the past decade, Emma Rothschild’s “Economic Sentiments: Adam Smith, Condorcet, and the Enlightenment,” claims him for sentimentalists more than for stockbrokers, as a man who believed that feelings of sympathy and engagement preceded impulses of industry and ambition. By cutting off “The Wealth of Nations” from his other great book, “The Theory of Moral Sentiments,” we not only cut off one half of Smith’s mind from the other but lobotomize our own understanding of modern life, making economics into a stand-alone statistical quasi-science rather than, as Smith intended, a branch of the humanities.

Phillipson’s new biography tries, very successfully, to pull together the two Smiths, letting us see how the man of feeling became the little god of finance. Tells about Smith’s childhood in Scotland, his friendship with philosopher David Hume, and the development of his ideas. ”


Comment
Niclolas Phillipson's intellectual biography of Adam Smith continues to get great reviews. If you haven't yet acquired a copy, endeavour to do so. I shall comment on his book soon. A conference in London is about to be held on the book with some of the major names among Smith scholars speaking and in attendance.

Labels: ,

Monday, July 05, 2010

A Potted Bio Of Adam Smith -Wrong In Parts

‘prescott’ writes in Bally bags an online a short biography of Adam Smith HERE:

Now, I am well known as an admirer of Adam Smith and his Works, but I mine is not unqualified in my admiration, especially for modern narratives. In particular, I am pretty cautious about what I include in his biography because a lot of ‘baggage’ is added to the known facts about his life and the checkable facts about his Works.

Hence, reading ‘Prescott’ on Adam Smith, I was struck immediately by the clear errors in his/her account in his article. In the interests of accuracy, I comment on ‘Prescott’s’ main errors:

‘Adam Smith: Capitalism’s Founding Father’

[Adam Smith did not found ‘capitalism’ (the word was not invented in English until 1854 (See Thackeray’s novel, ‘The Newcomes’ and check the Oxford English Dictionary). Smith observed what he called ‘the age of commerce’, which had been under way in Greco-Roman times and re-emerged after the fall of Rome (5th century) in Europe from 14th-15-century. No known individual founded ‘capitalism’, certainly not Adam Smith]

‘Adam Smith … best known for his classic treatise An Inquiry Into the Nature and Causes of the Wealth of Nations, he is credited with establishing the discipline of political economics.’

[Adam Smith did not ‘establish the discipline of political economy’, which was and remained a sub-topic within the ‘discipline’ of Moral Philosophy in Scottish Universities before him. Others wrote on political economy before Adam Smith (for example, Sit James Steuart, An Inquiry into the Principles of Political Œconomy, 1767, 2 volumes, Millar and Cadell, London.]

‘The ideas put forward in his work represented a radical departure from the then-dominant economic policy and philosophy of mercantilism, which had held sway in Europe for three centuries.’

[Basically true, but many of the ideas behind ‘mercantile political economy’ live on in the minds of many politicians and voters]

‘So profound was the impact of Wealth of Nations that it is generally considered the most important economic work ever written. Terms that are commonly used today, such as “invisible hand” and “division of labor,” had their genesis in Smith’s treatise.’

[An exaggeration but excusable, as most people have never read Wealth Of Nations’. However, ‘the division of labour’ did not have its ‘genesis’ in ‘Smith’s treatise: Plato wrote about in classical times (The Republic), as did Sir William Petty in the 1683, (Essay in Political Arithmetic). Smith made no claim to have done so; he referred (Wealth Of Nations) to the phenomena has having been ‘very often taken notice of’ by others. Smith’s arithmetic data on pin making came from Diderot’s Enclyclopedie (1751-57; see Peaucelle. J.-L. 2006), though he visited a small pin-factory himself. As for ‘an “invisible hand”, which is well known (even ubiquitous) today, his use of the famous 18th-century metaphor has no connection to its modern interpretation by economists (see Lost Legacy passim].

‘He was apparently greatly influenced by Scottish philosopher Francis Hutcheson, whose theories on moral sense were a basis for Smith’s own ethical speculations later in life.

[Professor Hutcheson was Smith’s tutor and certainly influenced him, but on ‘moral sense’ Smith took a quite different line to Hutcheson on the source of our moral sentiments; see Smith’s Theory of Moral Sentiments, 1759.]

‘Smith furthered his studies at Oxford for seven years and during this period became attracted to the atheistic ideas of another Scottish ‘Kobe V’ (sic!) philosopher, David Hume, with whom he would later form a close friendship.

[Hume never admitted to being ‘atheistic’; Smith was too careful to associate openly with atheism; he was not a Christian but hid his views – in his day it was too dangerous to known as an ‘atheist’, and risky to be a ‘deist’.]

‘Through this experience Smith gained important contacts with French intellectuals, including Voltaire, as well as firsthand exposure to the French economic policy of mercantilism. The policy advocated government control over industry and trade based on the theory that the nation would be strong as long as exports exceeded imports.’

[The French Physiocrats, with whom he associated, denied that ‘trade and manufacture’ produced ‘wealth’ –they considered them ‘sterile’ because only agriculture produced ‘wealth’ - ideas which Smith totally rejected.]

Smith objected to the French government’s interference in free trade through prohibitive duties on foreign goods. Many of his ideas in Wealth of Nations no doubt began to coalesce during this period.’

[Smith’s ideas on political economy were formed years before he visited France, as can be seen in his “Lectures on Jurisprudence’ (1762-3) and delivered at Glasgow University during 1751-63. The French influence came later.]

‘Smith also argued [economies] …could work most effectively in the absence of government interference. Such a laissez-faire—that is, “leave alone” or “allow to be”—policy (a term popularized by Wealth of Nations) would, in his opinion, kobe iv (sic!) encourage the most efficient operation of private and commercial enterprises.’

[Smith did not advocate ‘laissez-faire’ – he never used such words in Wealth Of Nations, nor anywhere else. He did not popularize the ‘term’ in Wealth Of Nations. He objected to mercantile interventions in commerce (particularly in legalising monopolies, tariffs, and prohibitions )but not to all government regulations (banking for example, contract laws, and the Navigation Acts).]

‘He also held that individuals acting in their own self-interest would naturally Kobe V (sic!) seek out economic activities that provided the greatest financial rewards. Smith was convinced that this self-interest would in turn maximize the economic well-being of society as a whole (see “The Achilles Heel of Capitalism”).’

{Smith was suspicious of the benign self-interest of ‘merchants and manufacturers’ – he hardly said a good word for them in their practices; if allowed by law a ‘free hand’ they narrowed the competition and raised prices; His reference to some , but not all, traders investing locally an raising national output was a reference to the arithmetic law that the whole is the sum of its parts, not a benign law that their self-interest necessarily benefitted society.]

‘It is not coincidental that such democratic, egalitarian views arose simultaneously with the American Revolution and only just preceded the French Revolution of 1789.’

[Wealth Of Nations was coincidental to, not linked to, the American Revolution nor t the French Revoluton. Wealth Of Nations was due for publication in 1773, but he delayed it to 1776, making final adjustments to the section on the British colonies in North America. The work had no influence on the Declaration of Independence.]

‘Modern capitalism traces its roots to Adam Smith and his Wealth of Nations, which has served, perhaps more than any other economic work, as a guide to the formulation of nations’ economic policies.’ Subsequent theories have altered governments’ role in economic policy, particularly the Keynesian ideas of the 20th century. Notwithstanding, Smith and his theories continue to occupy an important position in the development of economic thought.’

[An exaggeration. American and British governments – indeed most governments in Europe and in the modern world – largely ignored Smith’s critique of mercantile political economy, and his policy hostility to colonies, and his preference for freer trade, and his hostility to the almost universal habit of ‘jealousy of trade’. In Smith’s day it was jealousy of France, then it became jealousy of Germany, today it’s gross suspicions of China.]

[PS: what is ‘Kobe 5’?]

UPDATE: A reader called 'nnn' sent in a comment, which I passed for publication but somehow it has 'disappeared'. Not wanting to appear censorious, I shall report that 'nnn' was 'critical', saying he/she didn't see why 'Prescott' had said anything 'wrong' and that my post was 'just words'. Having been on the net for many years, I recognise a Troll when one pops up, but I was about to offer my advice that 'nnn' looked up a course on 'English language comprehension, suited to his/her reading age.

Labels: , ,

Wednesday, June 09, 2010

A Blogger Re-reads Adam Smith's Definitive Biography


IMPORTANT NOTICE

ADAM SMITH’S LOST LEGACY HAS BEEN MOVED BY “BLOGGER”, THE HOST SITE, TO A NEW ADDRESS:


TO FOLLOW ALL 2083 POSTS (AND COUNTNG) FROM HERE TO 2012 AND BEYOND, PLEASE USE THE NEW ADDRESS.

THANK YOU

Gavin Kennedy



Kenneth Anderson writes the Volokh Consipiracy Blog HERE and posts:

“Mallaby on Soros and the Pound, and Some Other Summer Reading in Philosophy and Economics"

“The latter goes to my scholarly interest in what I have called the “moral psychology of finance,” and somtimes called “virtue economics” — not in the sense of distributional justice in the economy, but instead the Aristotlean sense of “virtue ethics” and its intersection among practical reason, attitudes and rationality, and affective behavior and rational choice. I am slowly re-reading Theory of Moral Sentiments, alongside Ian Simpson Ross’s exemplary Life of Adam Smith, a book I read with insufficient attention when it first appeared, but which I am re-reading with a great deal of care
.”

Comment
A good sign from Blogland.

The more that those interested in modern economics read about figures, like Adam Smith, from impeccable sources, such as Ian Simpson Ross’s excellent and, in my view definitive, biography of Adam Smith, the more likely we are going to see a re-appraisal of historical figures who have been captured by people with modern perspectives rather than what they actually wrote and contributed.

Note: A new, second edition of Ian Ross’s Life of Adam Smith, is due from Oxford University Press soon.

Last year, when he visited Edinburgh and I showed him round, and the plans for the sympathetic renovation of, Panmure House in Edinburgh, where Adam Smith lived from 1778-90, he told me that his new edition was about to be sent to the publishers.

I await an opportunity to re-read the book and catch-up with his latest thoughts.

Labels: